This link has been bookmarked by 37 people . It was first bookmarked on 13 Mar 2008, by Levy Rivers.
-
06 Nov 15
-
25 May 13
-
04 Sep 12
-
13 Aug 11
Len YablokoSocial network sites (SNSs) provide a new way to organize and navigate an egocentric social network. Are they a fad, briefly popular but ultimately useless? Or are they the harbingers of a new and more powerful social world, where the ability to maintain an immense network-a social "supernet"-fundamentally changes the scale of human society? This article presents signaling theory as a conceptual framework with which to assess the transformative potential of SNSs and to guide their design to make them into more effective social tools.
-
In Grooming, Gossip, and the Evolution of Language, Robin Dunbar (1996) argued eloquently that in human societies, language, especially gossip, has taken over the social function of grooming. Instead of removing lice from each other's hair, people check in with friends and colleagues, ask how they are doing, and exchange a few words about common acquaintances, the news, or the local sports team
-
-
03 Jul 11
-
31 May 10
Phil Liff-Grieffusing signaling theory to discuss the impact of SNS's
socialnetworking social_networking socialnetworks social_networks social_capita SNSl
-
12 Dec 09
-
11 Dec 09
Silvana GregorioDonath article - discussing the use of signaling theory as a framework for understanding mediated communication
socialmedia research virtual_community assignment article gold_dust
-
09 Nov 09
-
16 May 09
-
02 Apr 09
-
08 Mar 09
-
A tremendous amount of fashion exists on many SNSs, with images, movies, and jokes tracing network paths as they spread from user to user. For example, Facebook users can add applications to their profile; these programs, of which there are thousands, help users share books, movies, and music; play games; create maps of where they have been, and so forth. Many are social grooming aids for the information world—their fundamental message is "I'm thinking of you," conveyed via virtual gifts or imaginary zombie bites or by letting users throw virtual sheep at each other. The profile of the fashion-conscious user is studded with icons signaling application use, and one looks to the fashion leaders to learn which of the newest offerings are worth adopting, for while some are very clever or useful, others are badly designed and programmed. Using one of these applications displays one's fashion knowledge and status: Is it a cool new app or one that was going out of style a week ago? Does the sender have enough influence to be able to introduce something new and have it catch on, or will it just seem like a strange thing to do ("Why are you throwing a make-believe sheep at me?")?
In the public space of SNSs, information fashions can create virtual walls, allowing those in the know to recognize others within their subculture via their co
-
For example, if frequent profile updating is hypothesized to signal status, then an interesting study would be to examine whether frequent updaters are more influentia
-
nderstanding which costs have communicative value is important for designers. Efficiency and ease of use are common design goals. Yet if a design eliminates costs that had functioned as signaling costs, a decrease in reliability may have an unforeseen effect. Thus with information access, if the information itself is the end (as it is with "useful" information), making access easier is beneficial. When information is used to signal status, as it is with fashion, then making access easier accelerates the race, rather than increasing efficiency (D
-
erhaps their greatest potential is to augment personal information flow
-
hat of casual acquaintances, the weaker ties that would account for many of the connections in a social supernet?
-
s Granovetter (1973, 1983) demonstrated, a key strength of weak ties is their ability to provide a wide range of information. Despite the ubiquity of mass media, personal networks remain an important information source.
-
have adapted the signals they use to indicate and infer popularity, romantic interest, and social adeptness to this ubiquitously connected space (Herring, 2008). One
-
se; others have employees or software programs standing in. The interaction constitutes the celebrity as a sort of fantasy friend. Moreover, as the software improves and the interactions become more personalized, the line between real and fictional friend becomes blurred. Is this deception—or entertainment? When is the signal's form, i.e., the appearance of friendship, sufficient and when is its implied quality, i.e., a genuine sentiment, what is really desired? (Donath, in press; Turkle, 2006)
-
ne significant draw of SNSs is the appeal of ceaseless novelty—of seeing blog entries, getting new comments, seeing what has changed. Perhaps the basic pleasure that social network sites provide is endless novelty in
-
-
05 Feb 09
-
03 Feb 09
-
21 Nov 08
-
20 Nov 08
Howard RheingoldSocial network sites (SNSs) provide a new way to organize and navigate an egocentric social network. Are they a fad, briefly popular but ultimately useless? Or are they the harbingers of a new and more powerful social world, where the ability to maintain
-
This article presents signaling theory as a conceptual framework with which to assess the transformative potential of SNSs and to guide their design to make them into more effective social tools. It shows how the costs associated with adding friends and evaluating profiles affect the reliability of users' self-presentation; examines strategies such as information fashion and risk-taking; and shows how these costs and strategies affect how the publicly-displayed social network aids the establishment of trust, identity, and cooperation—the essential foundations for an expanded social world.
-
Using language to maintain ties and manage trust, people can form and manage more complex and extensive social networks.1
-
Communication technologies expand human social reach (Horrigan, Boase, Rainie, & Wellman, 2006). Email makes communication more efficient: Sending a message to numerous recipients is as easy as sending it to one, and its asynchrony means that there is little need to coordinate interaction. Contact management tools, from paper Rolodexes to complex software systems, increase one's ability to remember large numbers of people (Whittaker, Jones, & Terveen 2002).
-
Signaling theory, developed initially in economics (Spence, 1973a) and biology (Zahavi, 1975), models the relationship between signals and qualities, showing why certain signals are reliable and others are not. For a signal to be reliable, the costs of deceptively producing the signal must outweigh the benefits. The core of signaling theory is its analysis of the types of signals and situations that bring this about.
-
One class of signals, termed assessment signals, is inherently reliable, because producing the signal requires possessing the indicated quality.
-
Another class of signals, termed conventional signals, is not inherently reliable (Guilford & Dawkins, 1995; Maynard-Smith & Harper, 2003). Here the link between signal and quality is arbitrary, a matter of social convention. Rare in the animal world, conventional signals are very common in human communication. The self-descriptions in online profiles are mostly conventional signals—it is just as easy to type 24 or 62 as it is to enter one's actual age, or to put M rather than F as one's gender.
-
Dunbar (1996) argued that while new communication technologies could increase the flow of information, they would be unable to change basic social structure and scale. He claimed that people would need to fall back on face-to-face interaction in order to establish trust, rather than relying on what he call the "mere ciphers" people encounter in the mediated domain (Dunbar, 1996, p. 204).
-
one's display of connections signals one's trustworthiness (Donath & boyd, 2004). One of the most valuable contributions of SNSs is their potential to add trust to weak ties. Trusted weak ties are very useful sources of information, combining the heterogeneity that such ties generally have with the believability that comes with trust (Levin & Cross, 2004). Furthermore, SNSs can actually increase trustworthiness, by placing people within a context that can enforce social mores. SNSs make people aware that their friends and colleagues are looking at their self-presentation.
-
observers have been puzzled or concerned by seemingly irrational behavior on SNSs. Users may spend considerable time updating their pages, adding new pictures and music; the comments they send each other are often in the form of jokes and images. Why spend so much time on seemingly inconsequential changes of imagery and uninformative communication? Deep concerns have also been raised about young people who create overly revealing profile pages, in which they appear in provocative photographs or recount illegal activities such as drug use or underage drinking. Warnings about the dangers of doing so have stopped some, but not all. Why would someone choose to post such material once he or she was aware of the negative consequences? Signaling theory can help explain such behavioral phenomena.
-
Being in fashion—whether via physical clothing or online linking—signals fitness in the continuously changing information world. It signals status in a society where "information prowess"—i.e., having access to information, the ability (often termed taste) to distinguish between good and bad information, and the willingness to adapt to the changes brought by new information—is a fundamental part of the culture
-
It is perhaps ironic that at the point in history when people have the greatest ability to stay in touch with each other, they are the least dependent on personal relationships for daily survival. Modern markets make it possible to survive in social isolation and, by choice or circumstance, some people do. Yet most choose to live in a socially connected world of family, friends, co-workers, and acquaintances.
-
By increasing the number of weak ties one can maintain, social supernets have the potential to expand their users' range of information sources, while maintaining a socially local context of personal acquaintanceship.
-
-
25 Oct 08
-
22 Sep 08
-
04 Aug 08
wgm-notesSome theory about the events that matter - e.g. for tracking on a SLIK infographic.
social socialnetworking socialsoftware delicious socialmedia statistics infographic social media
-
Social network sites (SNSs) provide a new way to organize and navigate an egocentric social network. Are they a fad, briefly popular but ultimately useless? Or are they the harbingers of a new and more powerful social world, where the ability to maintain an immense network—a social "supernet"—fundamentally changes the scale of human society? This article presents signaling theory as a conceptual framework with which to assess the transformative potential of SNSs and to guide their design to make them into more effective social tools. It shows how the costs associated with adding friends and evaluating profiles affect the reliability of users' self-presentation; examines strategies such as information fashion and risk-taking; and shows how these costs and strategies affect how the publicly-displayed social network aids the establishment of trust, identity, and cooperation—the essential foundations for an expanded social world.
-
-
01 Aug 08
zpinheadSocial network sites (SNSs) provide a new way to organize and navigate an egocentric social network. Are they a fad, briefly popular but ultimately useless? Or are they the harbingers of a new and more powerful social world, where the ability to maintain
web2.0 socialsoftware socialnetworks theory supernets trends
-
31 Jul 08
-
18 Apr 08
-
13 Mar 08
-
It shows how the costs associated with adding friends and evaluating profiles affect the reliability of users' self-presentation; examines strategies such as information fashion and risk-taking; and shows how these costs and strategies affect how the publicly-displayed social network aids the establishment of trust, identity, and cooperation—the essential foundations for an expanded social world.
-
It makes reputation possible—individuals benefit from the experience of others in determining who is nice, who does good work, and who should be shunned for their dishonest ways. Using language to maintain ties and manage trust, people can form and manage more complex and extensive social networks.1
-
The argument begins with an introduction to signaling theory. The next section uses this theory to examine how the fundamental structure of SNSs can bring greater trust and reliability to online self-presentations, how specific site design decisions enhance or weaken their trust-conferring ability, and how seemingly pointless or irrational behaviors, such as online fashion and risk taking, actually signal social information. The final section examines the transformative possibilities of social supernets—not only whether SNSs may bring them about, but if so, in what ways they might change our society.
-
An emphasis of this article is on ways of achieving reliable information about identity and affiliations. There are situations where ephemeral, hidden, or multiple identities are desirable. However, minimal online identity has been easy to create, while it is harder to establish more grounded identities in a fluid and nuanced way. A primary goal of this article is to understand how reliability is encouraged or enforced.
-
Signaling theory, developed initially in economics (Spence, 1973a) and biology (Zahavi, 1975), models the relationship between signals and qualities, showing why certain signals are reliable and others are not. For a signal to be reliable, the costs of deceptively producing the signal must outweigh the benefits. The core of signaling theory is its analysis of the types of signals and situations that bring this about
-
termed assessment signals
-
conventional signals
-
The self-descriptions in online profiles are mostly conventional signals—it is just as easy to type 24 or 62 as it is to enter one's actual age, or to put M rather than F as one's gender. Conventional signals are kept honest through the outside intervention of laws and social mores.
-
However, costs may discourage deception but not be high enough to guarantee honesty. The SNS LinkedIn requires that users provide the email address of the person with whom they wish to connect; this makes deceptively claiming to know someone costlier, but it certainly does not prevent all contact by strangers, especially for those with published email addresses.
-
Dunbar (1996) argued that while new communication technologies could increase the flow of information, they would be unable to change basic social structure and scale. He claimed that people would need to fall back on face-to-face interaction in order to establish trust, rather than relying on what he call the "mere ciphers" people encounter in the mediated domain (Dunbar, 1996, p. 204).
-
SNS users represent themselves with a profile, which includes a self-description, comments from other users, and the technology's defining feature, a list of links to chosen other members. The self-description can include pictures, affiliations, career goals, and other personal details. Alone, these are conventional signals, easily faked; even references to favorite obscure books and other displays of esoteric knowledge may have simply been copied from another's page. Yet the links to other members implies that they have vetted this description as true—although it is important to note that "true" means "true to the mores of our community," which can range from strict adherence to known facts to highly imaginative role-playing (boyd & Heer, 2006; Donath & boyd, 2004; Lenhart & Madden, 2007b).
-
Thus, one's display of connections signals one's trustworthiness (Donath & boyd, 2004). One of the most valuable contributions of SNSs is their potential to add trust to weak ties. Trusted weak ties are very useful sources of information, combining the heterogeneity that such ties generally have with the believability that comes with trust (Levin & Cross, 2004). Furthermore, SNSs can actually increase trustworthiness, by placing people within a context that can enforce social mores. SNSs make people aware that their friends and colleagues are looking at their self-presentation.
-
When people indiscriminately add connections, others who trusted their judgment can suffer and will eventually cease trusting them as a source for useful vouching. Site design influences this: Sites designed to make adding connections as easy as possible, emphasizing indiscriminate network growth, create networks that do little to increase trust or trustworthiness.
-
On sites with higher costs for creating a link, the observer has reason to believe that the links represent genuine relationships. Members of aSmallWorld are careful to request connections only with others whom they are sure wish to be linked to them, since they can be banished for having a few link requests declined (Price, 2006).
-
The meaning of these links is also personally subjective. For some people, listing someone as a "friend" on a social network site is an indication of personal and positive acquaintance. Others are far more casual, willing to add friends indiscriminately (boyd, 2006). This has ramifications for the reliability of the profile itself. Viewers may trust the self-created content of a profile if they believe that its links are to people who know that user well, while links that they believe have only minimal connection add little credence.
-
-
20 Nov 07
-
13 Nov 07
-
11 Nov 07
Suvi KorhonenSocial network sites (SNSs) provide a new way to organize and navigate an egocentric social network.
socialnetworking identity networks privacy research secondlife social online signals trends dunbar for:matrixx2.01 for:tulevaisuus
-
02 Nov 07
paul jonesAbstract
Social network sites (SNSs) provide a new way to organize and navigate an egocentric social network. Are they a fad, briefly popular but ultimately useless? Or are they the harbingers of a new and more powerful social world, where the ability3d secondlife social socialmedia socialnetwork socialnetworking socialnetworks web2.0 jomc490 privacy
Would you like to comment?
Join Diigo for a free account, or sign in if you are already a member.