Author is stated, job title
LEAST AND MOST CREDIBLE
Most Credible:
Deadly Attack at Kabul Restaurant Hints at Changing Climate for Foreigners by the New York Times
I feel this article is most credible of the 5 for the following reasons:
In my opinion, the authors intent of the entire article was to inform without any bias or political or personal agenda. The maintained an informative yet human element of the story without getting off track and "sticking to the facts", i.e.: using proper citation, using credible sources and offering a fact based information or a historical back story if you will, of what the environment was like in Kabul prior to the bombings). This particular article by the NY Times in comparison to the others, incorporated all 10 of the 10 C's as well as many elements within each individual "C" (i.e.: Content, Credibility, Continuity, etc...). Compared to some other articles I read on the same topic, I can say I actually felt I was informed on an historical, factual, non-satiric, level, which is why I rated this article a 98 out of 100.
Least Credible:
California Governor proclaims state in drought by Fox News.
I was surprised this was so lacking in most of areas of the 10 C’s. The article was condensed, abbreviated in content and lacking citations and credibility. There was no author indicated and seem to use second hand sources for the entire story. I was shocked considering this was even posted on Fox News. The Lexis Nexis article was clearly better, albeit not by much, but still better than this one.
Lexis Nexis - FS
News Website/Publication: South China Morning Post -
URL of Article: http://www.lexisnexis.com.oclc.fullsail.edu:81/lnacui2api/auth/checkbrowser.do;jsessionid=A422ACDFD4AB141130B927EDF145F7AA.1GWQPWCatxZHGGLWxhj9Q?ipcounter=1&cookieState=0&rand=0.4199064266799618&bhjs=1&bhqs=1
Title of Article: L.N.: Smoking ban planned by year's end;
Health agency's pledge for nationwide regulation outlawing smoking in public places seen as first timetable towards meeting WHO commitment
Author(s): Zhuang Pinghui pinghui.zhuang@scmp.com
Author(s) description, job title or background: None
Date and Timestamp: January 19 2014 00:45:55
Is the article complete, or do you think it could be revised? Could be revised
What aspects of the article could change or need updating? Could have used more applicable statistics and direct quotes and findings from research by authorities in that specific area.
Is anyone quoted directly within the article? Yes
How are they described? Where they work and position title
Is there a digital literacy or online experience point of view to the story? What is it? No
Summarize the article in your own words with the space of a tweet (140 characters)
Does the article offer the reader an opportunity to write a comment or repost to social media? No
Did you find this same article when you searched for it in the Lexis-Nexis database? If so, list the URL. If not, list a similar article that you found in the search results. Did not find the exact article - this is the similar one
What information or metadata did you find in Lexis-Nexis that was not listed on the original website? n/a
What was the 10 C's score for the original article?
What was the 10 C's score for the Lexis Nexis article? 61 - Borderline Acceptable
News Website/Publication: Published by HT Syndication with permission from Right Vision News.
URL of Article: http://www.lexisnexis.com.oclc.fullsail.edu:81/lnacui2api/api/version1/getDocCui?oc=00240&hnsd=f&hgn=t&lni=5B9R-2XV1-F12F-F1C8&hns=t&perma=true&hv=t&hl=t&csi=354856&secondRedirectIndicator=true
Title of Article: Tharoor's wife found dead after Twitter controversy
Author(s): Does not state a specific person - only the newspaper the article derived from
Author(s) description, job title or background: N/A (see above)
Date and Timestamp: January 19, 2014 Sunday
Is the article complete, or do you think it could be revised? I felt it was complete
What aspects of the article could change or need updating? In my opinion, the author would need to be indicated, other than that, it was direct and to the point. Preferred it to the original article.
Is anyone quoted directly within the article? Yes
How are they described? By name/job title/responsibility
Is there a digital literacy or online experience point of view to the story? What is it? Yes. It is regarding a controversy over what was found in a twitter account by the Indian ministers wife.
Summarize the article in your own words with the space of a tweet (140 characters): Wife of Indian minister was found dead only days after finding compromising tweets in husbands twitter acct.
Does the article offer the reader an opportunity to write a comment or repost to social media? Not to repost, but did list the editors email address for queries.
Did you find this same article when you searched for it in the Lexis-Nexis database? If so, list the URL. If not, list a similar article that you found in the search results. Same article was not found in Lexis-Nexis.
What information or metadata did you find in Lexis-Nexis that was not listed on the original website? Lexis-Nexis article seemed to me to give more of a back story between the couple with more quotes from the minister.
What was the 10 C's score for the original article? 77
What was the 10 C's score for the Lexis Nexis article? 64, but only due to lack of multimedia, navigation and miscellaneous aspects to the article. Still believe this was a better written article than the original.
News Website/Publication: Web-blog
URL of Article: http://www.lexisnexis.com.oclc.fullsail.edu:81/lnacui2api/auth/checkbrowser.do;jsessionid=74385B5E9EC9620F15C0BFD8C3A04CE9.nfuSRc0uhBzHSYImESdNnA?ipcounter=1&cookieState=0&rand=0.7971498591417494&bhjs=1&bhqs=1
Title of Article: Hoboken mayor says Christie camp used Sandy relief money as political hostage tool
Author(s): (The Moderate Voice:http://www.themoderatevoice.com/ Delivered by Newstex)
Author(s) description, job title or background: Not indicated
Date and Timestamp: January 18, 2014 Saturday 6:01 PM EST
Is the article complete, or do you think it could be revised? Complete, no revision needed in my opinion.
What aspects of the article could change or need updating? None
Is anyone quoted directly within the article? Yes
How are they described? Described by name/job title/employer
Is there a digital literacy or online experience point of view to the story? What is it? Not in my opinion
Summarize the article in your own words with the space of a tweet (140 characters) Hoboken mayor alleging corruption and bribery towards her from NJ governor Christie's office for development project he backed.
Does the article offer the reader an opportunity to write a comment or repost to social media? No
Did you find this same article when you searched for it in the Lexis-Nexis database? If so, list the URL. If not, list a similar article that you found in the search results. No, not the same, link listed about in bookmark.
What information or metadata did you find in Lexis-Nexis that was not listed on the original website? Lexis-Nexis article provided links to references & similar information which is found in the original article.
What was the 10 C's score for the original article? 97
What was the 10 C's score for the Lexis Nexis article? 88
News Website/Publication: The New York Times
URL of Article: http://www.lexisnexis.com.oclc.fullsail.edu:81/lnacui2api/api/version1/getDocCui?oc=00240&hnsd=f&hgn=t&lni=5B9X-M961-JBG3-60VJ&hns=t&perma=true&hv=t&hl=t&csi=6742&secondRedirectIndicator=true
Title of Article: Deadly Attack at Kabul Restaurant Hints at Changing Climate for Foreigners
Author(s): By AZAM AHMED and MATTHEW ROSENBERG; Habib Zahori contributed reporting.
Author(s) description, job title or background: n/a
Date and Timestamp: January 19, 2014
Is the article complete, or do you think it could be revised? It's complete. Although I noticed it was a simplified, abbreviated version of the original, simply excerpts.
What aspects of the article could change or need updating? None that I'm aware of.
Is anyone quoted directly within the article? Yes
How are they described? Name/position/job title/where they worked
Is there a digital literacy or online experience point of view to the story? What is it? Within the story no.
Summarize the article in your own words with the space of a tweet (140 characters): The article details the happenings of the bombing at Kabul and how the affects it will have on foreign nationals in the region.
Does the article offer the reader an opportunity to write a comment or repost to social media? No.
Did you find this same article when you searched for it in the Lexis-Nexis database? If so, list the URL. If not, list a similar article that you found in the search results. No. The same article does not exist. *Please see above*
What information or metadata did you find in Lexis-Nexis that was not listed on the original website? None that's I'm aware of.
What was the 10 C's score for the original article? 98
What was the 10 C's score for the Lexis Nexis article? 84
News Website/Publication: The New York Times
URL of Article: Stated above: http://www.lexisnexis.com.oclc.fullsail.edu:81/lnacui2api/api/version1/getDocCui?oc=00240&hnsd=f&hgn=t&lni=5B9N-SFG1-DXY4-X4FV&hns=t&perma=true&hv=t&hl=t&csi=6742&secondRedirectIndicator=true
Title of Article: California Watches Bad Drought Grow Worse
Author(s): NORIMITSU ONISHI and MALIA WOLLAN; Norimitsu Onishi reported from Norden, and Malia Wollan from San Francisco.
Author(s) description, job title or background: n/a
Date and Timestamp: January 18, 2014 Saturday
Is the article complete, or do you think it could be revised? I felt the article was complete and better than the original article.
What aspects of the article could change or need updating? I wouldn't.
Is anyone quoted directly within the article? Yes.
How are they described? Name/where they lived/where they worked/position title/employer
Is there a digital literacy or online experience point of view to the story? What is it? None that I could see.
Summarize the article in your own words with the space of a tweet (140 characters): Article explains the affects the lack of rainfall has had on CA and agriculture and possible affects for years to come.
Does the article offer the reader an opportunity to write a comment or repost to social media? NO and no.
Did you find this same article when you searched for it in the Lexis-Nexis database? If so, list the URL. If not, list a similar article that you found in the search results. This is not the original; http://www.lexisnexis.com.oclc.fullsail.edu:81/lnacui2api/api/version1/getDocCui?oc=00240&hnsd=f&hgn=t&lni=5B9N-SFG1-DXY4-X4FV&hns=t&perma=true&hv=t&hl=t&csi=6742&secondRedirectIndicator=true
What information or metadata did you find in Lexis-Nexis that was not listed on the original website? In my opinion it gave a far more detailed look into the affects and aftermath of what a drought truly entails and how it affects the people and the CA economy.
What was the 10 C's score for the original article? 66
What was the 10 C's score for the Lexis Nexis article? 79
Internet News Sources
News Website/Publication: NBCNews.Com
URL of Article: http://behindthewall.nbcnews.com/_news/2014/01/18/22341088-can-china-really-stop-350-million-people-from-smoking?lite
Title of Article: Can China really stop 350 million people from smoking?
Author(s): Ed Flanagan, NBC News' Zoe Zhang contributed to this report
Author(s) description, job title or background: Producer, NBC News
Date and Timestamp: Sat Jan 18, 2014 4:02 AM EST
Is the article complete, or do you think it could be revised? I felt the article was complete
What aspects of the article could change or need updating? None
Is anyone quoted directly within the article? Yes
How are they described? Where they work/business they own, where workplace is located and their position title
Is there a digital literacy or online experience point of view to the story? Not in my opinion.
Summarize the article in your own words with the space of a tweet (140 characters): This article explains the hurdles China must jump & what must happen for the smoking ban to be implemented.
Does the article offer the reader an opportunity to write a comment or repost to social media? Yes you can comment and yes you can repost to social media
Did you find this same article when you searched for it in the Lexis-Nexis database? No, the same article is not in Lexis-Nexis
If not, list a similar article that you found in the search results: Notated above in Lexis-Nexis section
What information or metadata did you find in Lexis-Nexis that was not listed on the original website? None, LN was an abbreviated version of the original.
What was the 10 C's score for the original article? 85 - Good
What was the 10 C's score for the Lexis Nexis article? 61- Borderline Acceptable
________________________________________________________
Content: Current article, latest edition, Title and author identified, intent is to communicate the growing concern of Chinese government regarding a large portion of the population being affected by smoking as well as 2nd hand smoke
Credibility: Purpose is to inform
Critical Thinking: Author, publisher is easily identifiable
Copyright: n/a
Citation: uses proper citation of sources/quotes
Continuity: Internet site is constantly updated and is currently free. Should continue to be as well. Can rely on up-to-date information
Censorship: n/a
Connectivity: Article is viewable by all web browsers and is easily accessible by a variety of connections (i.e.: traditional desktop, laptop, tablet, phone)
Comparability: site does contain comparable and complete information - over time, date will inevitably change in regard to this article and sources of this info can be identified
Context: context of my research is to determine if the article is credible
Author is stated, job title
News Website/Publication: USAToday (Contribution by Associated Press)
URL of Article: http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/world/2014/01/18/india-minister-wife-dead/4636121/
Title of Article: Wife of India minister found dead after Twitter spat
Author(s): William M. Welch, USA TODAY (Contribution by Associated Press)
Author(s) description, job title or background: None indicated
Date and Timestamp: 5:30 p.m. EST January 18, 2014
Is the article complete, or do you think it could be revised? In my opinion it could have been revised to include the reaction of other government officials, the citizens of India and/or how this could affect the ministers ability to do his job.
What aspects of the article could change or need updating? I don't think anything necessarily needs changing/updating, just additions.
Is anyone quoted directly within the article? Yes
How are they described? By job title, where they work
Is there a digital literacy or online experience point of view to the story? What is it? Yes, the premise of situation was centered around information found on social media (Twitter)
Summarize the article in your own words with the space of a tweet (140 characters): The article is about the mysterious "death" of the Indian ministers wife accused him of having an affair.
Does the article offer the reader an opportunity to write a comment or repost to social media? Yes and yes
Did you find this same article when you searched for it in the Lexis-Nexis database? No, article was not in database
If so, list the URL. If not, list a similar article that you found in the search results:
http://www.lexisnexis.com.oclc.fullsail.edu:81/lnacui2api/api/version1/getDocCui?oc=00240&hnsd=f&hgn=t&lni=5B9R-2XV1-F12F-F1C8&hns=t&perma=true&hv=t&hl=t&csi=354856&secondRedirectIndicator=true
What information or metadata did you find in Lexis-Nexis that was not listed on the original website? Shown above in Lexis-Nexis section titled: Wife of Indian minister found dead.
What was the 10 C's score for the original article? 77
What was the 10 C's score for the Lexis Nexis article? 64
Author and time stamp
News Website/Publication: Huffington Post
URL of Article: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/01/18/christie-sandy-money_n_4622869.html
Title of Article: Mayor Claims Christie Camp Held Hurricane Sandy Money Hostage
Author(s): ??? - not stated, but many other news courses were used within the article.
Author(s) description, job title or background: N/A
Date and Timestamp: Posted: 01/18/2014 9:40 am EST - Updated: 01/18/2014 3:05 pm EST
Is the article complete, or do you think it could be revised? Very complete
What aspects of the article could change or need updating? None
Is anyone quoted directly within the article? Yes
How are they described? Described by name, job title, name of workplace and/or company
Is there a digital literacy or online experience point of view to the story? What is it? Video interview at the beginning of the article, but not as it pertains to the story itself.
Summarize the article in your own words with the space of a tweet (140 characters): Mayor Christie of NJ was alleged in holding Sandy funds from Hoboken mayor and would do so until she backed development project.
Does the article offer the reader an opportunity to write a comment or repost to social media? Yes, can comment and repost to social media.
Did you find this same article when you searched for it in the Lexis-Nexis database? If so, list the URL. If not, list a similar article that you found in the search results. No was not in Lexis-Nexis. http://www.lexisnexis.com.oclc.fullsail.edu:81/lnacui2api/auth/checkbrowser.do;jsessionid=74385B5E9EC9620F15C0BFD8C3A04CE9.nfuSRc0uhBzHSYImESdNnA?ipcounter=1&cookieState=0&rand=0.7971498591417494&bhjs=1&bhqs=1
What information or metadata did you find in Lexis-Nexis that was not listed on the original website?
What was the 10 C's score for the original article? 97
What was the 10 C's score for the Lexis Nexis article?
Currency
Time stamp, posted date & time/updated date & time
News Website/Publication: NYtimes.com
URL of Article: http://www.nytimes.com/2014/01/19/world/asia/afghanistan-restaurant-attack.html?hp
Title of Article: Deadly Attack at Kabul Restaurant Hints at Changing Climate for Foreigners
Author(s): By AZAM AHMED and MATTHEW ROSENBERG
Author(s) description, job title or background: none indicated
Date and Timestamp: JAN. 18, 2014
Is the article complete, or do you think it could be revised? I felt the article was more than complete.
What aspects of the article could change or need updating? None.
Is anyone quoted directly within the article? Yes
How are they described? name/ title/employer
Is there a digital literacy or online experience point of view to the story? What is it? None that I was aware of.
Summarize the article in your own words with the space of a tweet (140 characters): Article explains the bombings in Kabul and the aftermath the effects the bombing will have on foreigners.
Does the article offer the reader an opportunity to write a comment or repost to social media? Yes.
Did you find this same article when you searched for it in the Lexis-Nexis database? If so, list the URL. If not, list a similar article that you found in the search results. No. Was not in Lexis-Nexis.
What information or metadata did you find in Lexis-Nexis that was not listed on the original website? Both articles were good, but the NY Times article went into more depth about the backstory and explanation of the individuals who were killed in the bombing.
What was the 10 C's score for the original article? 98
What was the 10 C's score for the Lexis Nexis article? 84
News Website/Publication: Fox News
URL of Article: http://www.foxnews.com/us/2014/01/17/calif-governor-proclaims-state-in-drought/?intcmp=latestnews
Title of Article: Calif. governor proclaims state in a drought
Author(s): None listed (Associated Press?)
Author(s) description, job title or background: N/A
Date and Timestamp: Published January 17, 2014
Is the article complete, or do you think it could be revised? I definitely think it could be revised. It was not only abbreviated, but lacked in any kind of back story or affect it will have on the agricultural culture of CA and the nation.
What aspects of the article could change or need updating? More details, more citations and in-depth stories of the long term affects of the drought.
Is anyone quoted directly within the article? Yes
How are they described? Name/job title/employer
Is there a digital literacy or online experience point of view to the story? What is it? Not in my opinion
Summarize the article in your own words with the space of a tweet (140 characters): Article is about Jerry Brown saying how CA is in the worst drought since the 1800's.
Does the article offer the reader an opportunity to write a comment or repost to social media? No
Did you find this same article when you searched for it in the Lexis-Nexis database? If so, list the URL. If not, list a similar article that you found in the search results. No, I did not find the article. Lexis-Nexis article: http://www.lexisnexis.com.oclc.fullsail.edu:81/lnacui2api/api/version1/getDocCui?oc=00240&hnsd=f&hgn=t&lni=5B9N-SFG1-DXY4-X4FV&hns=t&perma=true&hv=t&hl=t&csi=6742&secondRedirectIndicator=true
What information or metadata did you find in Lexis-Nexis that was not listed on the original website? There was more in-depth stories of how the drought affects CA and the agriculture. It gives more of a personal point of view and how it will affect not only CA, but the rest of the nation and world as a whole.
What was the 10 C's score for the original article? 66
What was the 10 C's score for the Lexis Nexis article? 79
14 items | 28 visits
Understanding literacy tools; find, evaluate and communicate information using digital technologies; apply digital literacy tools and techniques to academic tasks, career activities and professional development.
Updated on Jul 18, 15
Created on Jan 18, 14
Category: Schools & Education
URL: