The arguments that Digi, Control4, and Schneider are making in their counter suit are very damning. If they hold up, it will wreck Sipco, and unravel their agreements with other parties. The heart of the argument is that the patents should not have been granted because prior art renders them obvious. In other words, mesh network structures are and were known, and some or all of the technology is in the public domain.
Earlier this year, Sipco expanded the scope of its patent enforcement activity to target players in the electric vehicle charging station space including Coulomb Technologies and ECOtality, as well as additional energy management, control system, and wireless companies such as EnergyHub, Jetlun, SmartLabs, ABB, and Ingersoll-Rand.