Skip to main contentdfsdf

Eathompson314's List: Ten C's Web Page Evaluation

  • Instructions

      • After your evaluation of the article, discuss ideas about the prompts below: 

         
           
        • Did the evaluation process change how you viewed the information in the article?
        •  
        • How can evaluating Internet resources help in your academic and professional work?
        •  
        • Do you think any of the 10 Cs listed are more or less important than the others?
    • WEB PAGE EVALUATION

      Title of Web Site: URL:

      Directions: Use your judgment in allotting points for the various categories. Total the points for score.

      Currency (0 to 15 Points)

      The site has the date of last revision posted.

      The site has been updated recently.

      Frequency of planned updates and revisions is stated.

      Content (0 to 15 Points)

      The information will be useful to our curriculum and/or student interest.

      This information is not available in any other format elsewhere in my library.

      The information on the topic is thorough.

      The information is accurate.

      The purpose of the page is obvious.

      The information is in good taste.

      The page uses correct spelling and grammar.

      Authority (0 to 10 Points)

      The authors are clearly identified.

      The authors and/or maintainers of the site are authorities in their field.

      There is a way to contact the author (s) via e-mail or traditional mail.

      You can easily tell from the domain name where the page originates.

      • Currency: 7<br/>Although the date of post is given, it does not state when or if a revision has been done on this article. The site itself is updated by the post upload date. There is no statement of revision frequency. Quotes are said to be delayed 15 minutes. Which makes reading a bit annoying when you must refresh to be sure you haven't missed information.



        Content: 15

        Since the subject matter has to do with police, the general public and civil rights, it is of great interest to everyone. All other points are relevant to this page topic and the information is accurate according to other verifying documentations such as videos (Youtube; Ferguson;Mike Brown Shooting), news journalist reports(CNN, AP, Local News Coverage) and first person accounts from individuals in attendance (Twitter, Youtube, Reddit, Facebook, Instagram).



        Authority: 8

        there is no clear indication on how to contact the author of the first article in the sequence.

    • Navigation (0 to 10 Points)

      You can tell from the first page how the site is organized and what options are available.

      The type styles and background make the page clear and readable.

      The links are easy to identify.

      The links are logically grouped.

      The layout is consistent from page to page.

      There is a link back to the home page on each supporting page.

      The links are relevant to the subject.

      The icons clearly represent what is intended.

      Experience (0 to 10 Points)

      The page fulfills its intended purpose.

      The page is worth the time.

      The page's presentation is eye-catching.

      The site engages the visitor to spend time there.

      Multimedia (0 to 10 Points)

      Sound, graphics or video enhance the site's message.

      Treatment (0 to 10 Points)

      Any biases towards the subject matter can be easily identified.

      The page is free from stereotyping.

      The page is age appropriate for content and vocabulary for its intended audience.

      Access (0 to 5 Points)

      You can connect quickly to the page.

      The page is available through search engines.

      The page loads quickly.

      You can choose whether to download smaller images, text-only, or non-frame versions.

      Miscellaneous (0 to 15 Points)

      The page has received an award(s).

      • Navigation: 10



        Experience: 10



        Multimedia: 10



        Treatment: 10



        Access: 5



        Miscellaneous: 15

    1 more annotation...

  • Article of Evaluation

    • The city will establish a citizen review board to offer a public check on police conduct, and will reform municipal tickets and fines that have become the city’s second-greatest source of revenue and made Ferguson an outlier in the state for the number of arrest warrants served per person, the New York Times reports.
    • City officials will vote to cap the total fines collected by the city, the lack of which critics say has created an incentive to issue more tickets and arrest warrants, and will also offer a window of reprieve for pending arrest warrants.

    2 more annotations...

    • “In Ferguson, our investigation will assess the police department’s use of force, including deadly force. It will analyze stops, searches, and arrests. And it will examine the treatment of individuals detained at Ferguson’s city jail, in addition to other potentially discriminatory policing techniques and tactics that are brought to light,” Holder said.

       

      The Department was given the legal authority to open “pattern or practice” investigations in 1994 and in the past five years it has opened 20 such investigations across the country.

    • The Aug. 9 encounter prompted riots and days of protests in the St. Louis suburb, and the Department of Justice is already separately investigating whether any civil rights laws were violated during the shooting of the teenager, Michael Brown.

       

      Attorney General Eric Holder said at a news conference on Thursday that city leaders would be cooperating with the investigation into whether there was a pattern or practice of discrimination in the force. He also said the so-called “pattern or practice” investigation could be expanded to include police departments in neighboring jurisdictions.

    2 more annotations...

    • Governor Jay Nixon said he saw encouraging signs of 'folks getting back to their normal routines'

       

      Missouri Governor Jay Nixon lifted a state of emergency for the city of Ferguson Wednesday, arguing that weeks of unrest over the shooting of an unarmed teenager had finally subsided.

    • “Over the past week, we’ve seen students getting back to school, businesses reopening their doors and folks getting back to their normal routines,” Nixon said in a statement. “This progress is a testament to the efforts of community and faith leaders, working alongside state and local law enforcement officers, to bring peace to the streets of Ferguson and much-needed stability to its citizens.”

    1 more annotation...

1 - 12 of 12
20 items/page
List Comments (0)