Skip to main content

Todd Suomela's Library tagged macroeconomic   View Popular

10 Aug 09

Lucas roundtable: Ask the right questions | Free exchange | Economist.com

But all the tools in the world are useless if we lack the imagination needed to build the right models. Models are built to answer specific questions.

www.economist.com/...s_roundtable_ask_the_right.cfm - Preview

economics macroeconomic recession failure model questions modeling

  • We need to take a close look at how the sociology of our profession led to an outcome where people were made to feel embarrassed for even asking certain types of questions. People will always be passionate in defense of their life's work, so it's not the rhetoric itself that is of concern, the problem comes when factors such as ideology or control of journals and other outlets for the dissemination of research stand in the way of promising alternative lines of inquiry.

    I don't know for sure the extent to which the ability of a small number of people in the field to control the academic discourse led to a concentration of power that stood in the way of alternative lines of investigation, or the extent to which the ideology that markets prices always tend to move toward their long-run equilibrium values caused us to ignore voices that foresaw the developing bubble and coming crisis. But something caused most of us to ask the wrong questions, and to dismiss the people who got it right, and I think one of our first orders of business is to understand how and why that happened.

22 Jul 09

The Failure of Macroeconomics « ThinkMarkets

it is not simply a matter of finding the right explanation of the recent financial meltdown and recession. The search by most macroeconomists is constrained by a certain set of unquestioned methodological precepts. These precepts go to the heart of the conception of Economics as a Science.

thinkmarkets.wordpress.com/...the-failure-of-macroeconomics - Preview

economics macroeconomic methodology ideology scientism certainty mathematics modeling

21 Jul 09

Stumbling and Mumbling: Macroeconomics & the black box

Macroeconomics has traditionally ignored the inner workings of all companies. It has seen non-financial firms as mere production functions, transforming inputs into output in a stable (and smoothly differentiable) way. Regarding banks as black boxes for converting savings into loans is a natural consequence of paying insufficient heed to institutions.

stumblingandmumbling.typepad.com/...roeconomics-the-black-box.html - Preview

economics macroeconomic failure institutions

  • Herein, though, lies a quirk of history. There’s one significant figure who cautioned against this error - Marx. In Capital (ch 6) he criticized orthodox economists for ignoring “the hidden abode of production.”
    But mainstream economists - including Keynes - ignored him. They did so, in large part, because they were not especially interested in Marx’s question of how income was distributed between profits and wages.
    So, could it be that a by-product of a lack of interest in this question has been “black box” thinking that’s proven very costly for mainstream economics? The amazing thing is that macroeconomics managed so well for so long with this omission.





30 Jan 09

SSRN-The State of Macro by Olivier Blanchard

For a long while after the explosion of macroeconomics in the 1970s, the field looked like a battle field. Over time however, largely because facts do not go away, a largely shared vision both of fluctuations and of methodology has emerged. Not everything is fine. Like all revolutions, this one has come with the destruction of some knowledge, and suffers from extremism and herding. None of this is deadly however. The state of macro is good.

The first section sets the stage with a brief review of the past. The second argues that there has been broad convergence in vision, and the third reviews the specifics. The fourth focuses on convergence in methodology. The last looks at current challenges.

papers.ssrn.com/...papers.cfm - Preview

history economics macroeconomic 1970s 1980s 1990s

27 Jul 08

Economist's View: Macroeconomic Models and Monetary Policy

  • There is quite a bit of research on
    monetary policy that is devoted to the issues he is worried about, particularly the literature on adaptive learning. See

    here
    , and some of his publications
    here for
    and example from a European central bank. These ideas are also well-known and of considerable interest to
    the US Fed, e.g. one example is

    here
    , but there are many
    more.
    Some of the recent
    work
    of Chris Sims is also of interest in this regard:



    ...Most recently, theories that postulate deviations from the assumption of
    rational, computationally unconstrained agents have drawn attention. One branch
    of such thinking is in the behavioral economics literature (Laibson, 1997;
    Benabou and Tirole, 2001; Gul and Pesendorfer, 2001, e.g.), another in the
    learning literature (Sargent, 1993; Evans and Honkapohja, 2001, e.g.), another
    in the robust control literature (Giannoni, 1999; Hansen and Sargent, 2001;
    Onatski and Stock, 1999, e.g.).


    This paper suggests yet another direction for deviation from the seamless
    model, based on the idea that individual people have limited capacity for
    processing information. That people have limited information-processing capacity
    should not be controversial. It accords with ordinary experience, as do the
    basic ideas of the behavioral, learning, and robust control literatures. The
    limited information-processing capacity idea is particularly appealing, though,
    for two reasons. It accounts for a wide range of observations with a relatively
    simple single mechanism. And, by exploiting ideas from the engineering theory of
    coding, it arrives at predictions that do not depend on the details of how
    information is processed.

1 - 7 of 7
Showing 20 items per page

Highlighter, Sticky notes, Tagging, Groups and Network: integrated suite dramatically boosting research productivity. Learn more »

Join Diigo