Rudy Garns's Library tagged → View Popular, Search in Google
"Darwinian-minded analysts argue that Homo sapiens have an innate distaste for hierarchical extremes, the legacy of our long nomadic prehistory as tightly knit bands living by veldt-ready team-building rules: the belief in fairness and reciprocity, a capacity for empathy and impulse control, and a willingness to work cooperatively in ways that even our smartest primate kin cannot match."
Fairness is viewed differently by the haves and have-nots. The underlying emotions and desires aren't half as lofty as the ideal itself. The most recognizable emotion is resentment. Look at how children react to the slightest discrepancy in the size of their pizza slice compared with their siblings'. They shout, "That's not fair!" but never in a way transcending their own desires.
A new study shows that chimps sacrifice their own advantage if they earned it unfairly.
Human behaviors are often explained as hard-wired evolutionary leftovers of life on the savannah or during the Stone Age. But a study of one very modern behavior, fairness toward total strangers one will never meet again, suggests it evolved recently, and is rooted in culture rather than biology.
Read More http://www.wired.com/wiredscience/2010/03/evolution-of-fairness/#ixzz0iuGjRXg3
the study provides a solid blow to the idea that sex hormones affect our attitudes to trust or fairness, and it reminds us yet again to be cautious about relying too heavily on correlations. (Not Exactly Rocket Science)
We all like making connections between animals and humans. It seems that the closer animals are to humans, the easier it will be to explain the human phenomenon. But it may not help social and cognitive scientists to go too far too fast.
-
However, this does not show that monkeys are averse to inequity, only that they reject a lesser reward when better rewards are available. It can also be frustration or envy or even discouragement?
-
although they hunt collectively, neither dogs nor chimps seem to take into account individual contributions to the hunt when sharing meat (see here for instance). There is also evidence that chimps don't care about other's welfare,
- 1 more annotation(s)...
"Serotonin (5-HT) has long been implicated in social behavior and impulsivity, but the mechanisms through which it modulates self-control remain unclear. We observed the effects of manipulating 5-HT function on behavior in the Ultimatum Game, where players must decide whether to accept or reject fair or unfair monetary offers from another player. Participants with depleted 5-HT levels rejected a greater proportion of unfair, but not fair offers, without showing changes in mood, fairness judgments, basic reward processing, or response inhibition. Our results suggest that 5-HT plays a critical role in regulating emotion during social decision-making." -- Crockett et al., 10.1126/science.1155577 -- Science
in list: Neuroethics
"What's new is that the researchers were able to determine that an emotion-related region called the insula was responsible for encoding the equity of each option, whilst a reward-based region called the putamen was involved in encoding efficiency. In fact, differences in how sensitive each participant was to these two concerns was reflected in their levels of brain activity in these two regions.
The findings provide a biological perspective on age-old philosophical questions about distributive justice, and appear to support the view of thinkers such as David Hume and Adam Smith who argued that emotions play a fundamental role in moral decisions of this kind." (BPS RESEARCH DIGEST)
-
insula
-
putamen
"Researchers have linked low levels of serotonin in the brain to various mental states, including depression and impulsive, irrational behavior" Holden 2008 (605): 1, ScienceNOW
"Now, researchers at the California Institute of Technology have discovered that reason struggles with emotion to find equitable solutions, and have pinpointed the region of the brain where this takes place. The concept of fairness, they found, is processed in the insular cortex, or insula, which is also the seat of emotional reactions." (ScienceDaily)
in list: Neuroethics
"Researchers at Caltech said Friday they have pinpointed the part of the brain where reason grapples with emotion to hit upon equitable solutions. The concept of fairness, researchers found, is processed in the insular cortex, or insula, which also is the seat of emotional reactions. In other words, fairness is hard-wired into our brains. " (Pasadena Star-News)
in list: Neuroethics
According to research..."Compared with unfair offers of equal monetary value, fair offers led to higher happiness ratings and activation in several reward regions of the brain. Furthermore, the tendency to accept unfair proposals was associated with increased activity in right ventrolateral prefrontal cortex, a region involved in emotion regulation, and with decreased activity in the anterior insula, which has been implicated in negative affect." (Bownds' Mindblog)
in list: Neuroethics
Selected Tags
Related Tags
Top Contributors
-
accessibility
quick collection of accessib...
Items: 6 | Visits: 3
Created by: sontimalonti
-
The Spirit Level
Items: 5 | Visits: 4
Created by: C K
-
FairTax
The FairTax plan is a compre...
Items: 8 | Visits: 59
Created by: A Lutz
Diigo is about better ways to research, share and collaborate on information. Learn more »
Join Diigo
