Lisa Spiro's Library tagged → View Popular
Reinventing academic publishing online. Part I: Rigor, relevance and practice
While current computing practice abounds with innovations like online auctions, blogs, wikis, twitter, social networks and online social games, few if any genuinely new theories have taken root in the corresponding “top” academic journals. Those creating computing progress increasingly see these journals as unreadable, outdated and irrelevant. Yet as technology practice creates, technology theory is if anything becoming even more conforming and less relevant. We attribute this to the erroneous assumption that research rigor is excellence, a myth contradicted by the scientific method itself. Excess rigor supports the demands of appointment, grant and promotion committees, but is drying up the wells of academic inspiration. Part I of this paper chronicles the inevitable limits of what can only be called a feudal academic knowledge exchange system, with trends like exclusivity, slowness, narrowness, conservatism, self–involvement and inaccessibility. We predict an upcoming social upheaval in academic publishing as it shifts from a feudal to democratic form, from knowledge managed by the few to knowledge managed by the many. The technology trigger is socio–technical advances. The drive will be that only democratic knowledge exchange can scale up to support the breadth, speed and flexibility modern cross–disciplinary research needs. Part II suggests the sort of socio–technical design needed to bring this transformation about.
eLib Supporting Studies
It was recognised that there was a need for a number of studies to be carried out to support the Electronic Libraries Programme in various areas. There are currently therefore three main strands of supporting studies activity funded by eLib:
* Evaluative Studies, managed by the Tavistock Institute
* Preservation Studies, managed by BLRIC
* UKOLN-managed studies and workshops (resulting from MODELS and elsewhere)
The Peer-Review System Is Broken - The Chronicle Review - The Chronicle of Higher Education
Humanities Journals Cost Much More to Publish Than Science Periodicals - Chronicle.com
Very interesting study, but some flaws--high end publishing
ALA Conference 2009: Doomsday Clock Countdown at SPARC-ACRL Forum - 7/16/2009 - Library Journal
Press Launches Minnesota Archive Editions
collaboration with Amazon & Google
Selected Tags
Related Tags
publishing (97)
digital_scholarship (64)
openaccess (49)
authority (14)
peerreview (13)
digital_humanities (12)
science (9)
collaboration (7)
research (7)
copyright (6)
socialnetworking (5)
dh2008 (5)
web2.0 (5)
socialsoftware (5)
economics (4)
university_press (4)
ebooks (4)
blogging (4)
impact_factor (4)
Sponsored Links
Top Contributors
Groups interested in scholarl...
-
Scholarly Communication
Articles and sites on aspec...
Items: 40 | Visits: 2
Created by: Kay Cunningham
Highlighter, Sticky notes, Tagging, Groups and Network: integrated suite dramatically boosting research productivity. Learn more »
Join Diigo