Recent Bookmarks and Annotations
-
Japan, Australia Share Different Visions for East Asian Trade Bloc at Asean Meet - The Jakarta Globe on 2009-11-30
-
Rudd’s Asia-Pacific Community would include the US, Japan, China, India, Indonesia and “the other states of our region,” he said in a speech last year. Its purpose would be to cooperate on economic, political and security matters and dispel notions that a conflict in Asia may be inevitable, he said at the time.
Hatoyama, who came to office Sept. 16, said in a speech at the United Nations a week later that he would strive to create an East Asian community similar to the European Union. The goal was seen as potentially excluding the US after he published an opinion article in the New York Times in August arguing that “the era of US-led globalism is coming to an end.”
-
Japan pushes for East Asia bloc | Reuters on 2009-11-30
-
Making a case for an East Asian Community at a summit of Asian leaders in Thailand, Prime Minister Yukio Hatoyama said there should be some U.S. involvement in the bloc, which faces stiff obstacles including Japan's historic rivalry with China.
-
Hatoyama may also be trying to defuse U.S.-Japan tension over the long-planned reorganization of the American military presence in Japan, the first big test of ties between Washington and the new Japanese government.
-
untitled on 2009-11-24
-
The "dogmatists" assert that truth is discoverable. The "academics" deny that truth is discoverable. The "skeptics" suspend judgment and continue to search for conditions under which truth may be discovered.
-
Skepticism is different from nihilism. While nihilism asserts that nothing can be known, skepticism says that it is possible that some things may be known. Skepticism is also different from empiricism. While empiricism views experience as a source of knowledge, skepticism suspends judgment about whether knowledge is possible or impossible.
-
-
While the hedonist aims to enjoy pleasure and to avoid pain, the skeptic aims to achieve the tranquility of mind that is produced by being able to avoid errors of reasoning.
-
Skepticism applies the rule that things may always appear differently from the way that they actually appear. The appearance of an object may change for a perceiving subject if there is a change in the way in which the object is perceived by the subject or if there is some other change in the relation between the object and the subject. The appearance of an object may change over a period of time, or the object may become less apparent to the subject, or it may be only occasionally apparent to the subject.
-
re skeptical about something, then we neither affirm nor deny it.
-
at any criterion of truth can only be judged by another criterion, which can only be judged by another criterion, and so on ad infinitum
-
suspend judgment about the truth or falsehood of a logical proposition may be to suggest that there is some uncertainty about its truth or falsehood
-
Skepticism does not make any assertions about reality or unrealit
-
a suspension of judgement about whether there are any causal relations between events or phenomena
-
skeptic questions whether anything can be proved, because any proof must be proved by another proof, which must be proved by another proof, and so on ad infinitum. Thus, for the skeptic, there is no self-evident proof of anything
-
s Empiricus' skepticism attempts to avoid error by suspending judgment about questions which cannot be resolved with certainty. This suspension of judgment applies not only to metaphysical questions (such as the origin of the universe or the nature of ultimate reality), but also to ethical, aesthetic, and logical questions.
-
Skepticism is more a method of avoiding error than a method of finding truth. The skeptic avoids belief or disbelief in anything, because belief or disbelief may produce conflict instead of equanimity
-
Ancient Skepticism (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy) on 2009-11-24
-
Academic Skepticism, which comprises a skeptical phase of
Plato's Academy that stretches from the 3rd to the early 1st century
B.C.E
-
Pyrrhonism, which flourished during and after the 1st c. B.C.E., is
the most mature variant of ancient skepticism
-
-
the skeptic is someone who
has investigated the questions of philosophy but has “suspended
judgment” (practicing epochê) because he is unable
to resolve the differences a
-
ost mature skeptical perspective in ancient times is
Pyrrhonism.
-
Pyrrhonian leaves open the possibility that truth may be found.
W
-
ancient skeptics adopt an
attitude of oppositio
-
ributes a method of opposition to Academic
skepticism,
-
-
e setting of things in
opposition
-
-
-
oppose ideas to appearance
-
willing to cite whatever
evidence might seem to serve to demonstrate uncertain
-
o characterize times of social upheaval
-
skeptics' conclusion that truth is uncertain
is at odds with the “dogmatic” philosophies they reject,
but this conclusion may still be founded on a similar focus on opposing
arguments, antithesis, and conflicting points of view
-
Xenophanes was known for his claim
that no one knows clear truth; Democritus maintained that
“bastard” knowledge gained through the senses exists only
by convention; Plato's dialogues contained arguments pro and contra,
and cast doubt on everyday opinions; Diogenes of Sinope and other
Cynics dismiss philosophical speculation; Epictetus insists that
philosophers spend too much time on theory (En., 51); and so
on. The philosophies that such philosophers endorsed do not
incorporate a full fledged skepticism, but their influence
added impetus to the skeptics' moves in this direction.
-
Opposing interests and
perspectives were also manifest in debate, war, political rivalries and
a religion and mythology which pitted god against god, man against man
and even god against man.
-
Pyrrho left no writings, and many of the later comments about him
seem colored by anachronisms encouraged by his later status as the
figurehead for the Pyrrhonian “revival” of the 1st c. B.C.E.
S
-
-
-
Flintoff locates the origins of Pyrrho's philosophy in India, where
Pyrrho travelled in the court of Alexander the Great. It was on this
trip that Pyrrho was exposed to Indian ascetics (the so called
gymno-sophists — the “Naked Philosophers” of
India)
-
yrrho's skepticism may be an extension of aspects of Democritea
-
e
remained calm and pointed to a small pig which was calmly eating on the
deck,
-
the dogmatists say that they [the skeptics] abolish
life, in the sense that they throw out everything that goes to make up
a life. But the skeptics say that these charges are false. For they do
not abolish, say, sight, but only hold that we are ignorant of its
explanation….
-
the claims that things
“are” indifferent, unmeasurable and inarbitrable — as
claims about appearances.
-
Pyrrho's impact on his immediate contemporaries seems quite limited.
-
Cicero
defends a version of Academic skepticism, claiming that Plato is a
skeptic because he is always arguing pro and contra, states nothing
positively, inquires into everything, and makes no certain statements
(Ac 1.46).
-
nquire into
the conduct of life, which naturally cannot be directed without a
criterion, upon which happiness too, that is, the goal of life depends
for its reliability,
-
revolve around the
question whether it can be made consistent with an acceptance of a
practical criterion like the “reasonable” or, much more
fundamentally, the beliefs which daily life appears to require
-
Carneades' arguments against all criteria of knowledge,
Eusebius says that he did not suspend judgment on all matters
-
“non-evident” (non-apparent) and those that are
“non-apprehensible
-
arguments for and against the dialectical
interpretation of the Academics revolve around the question how the
Academics' views can be rendered most consistent.
-
t skeptics
inconsistently accept particular beliefs.
-
Whether or not he was a pure dialectician, Carneades' dexterity in
argument is the most notable feature of the extant evidence
-
ooks of Pyrrhonian Arguments propounded
the view that “the Pyrrhonist determines nothing, not even this,
that he determines nothing” (ibid.
-
Sextus Empiricus (ca. 200 C.E.):
(i) The Outlines of Pyrrhonism;
-
Against the Dogmatists, which consists of
“Against the Logicians” (2 books), “Against the
Physicists” (2 books), and “Against the Ethicists” (1
book); and
(iii) Against the Learned (Adversus Mathematicos),
w
-
The Pyrrhoneans' commitment to appearances is consolidated in a
“Practical Criterion” which was advocated as a
“standard of action” which allowed the Pyrrhonian to
“perform some actions and abstain from others.”
-
for we agree that at times they shiver and are thirsty and
have other feelings of this kind. But in these cases ordinary people
are afflicted by two sets of circumstances: by the feelings themselves,
and no less by believing that these circumstances are bad by nature.
Sceptics, who shed the additional opinion that each of these things is
bad in its nature, come off more moderately even in these cases
-
eir claim that they
accept appearances without committing themselves to belief.
-
Sextus Empiricus - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia on 2009-11-24
-
-
should suspend judgment about virtually all beliefs, that is, we should neither affirm any belief as true nor deny any belief as false.
-
-
s view is known as
Pyrrhonian skepticism, as distinguished from Academic skepticism, as practiced by
Carneades, which, according to Sextus, denies knowledge altogether.
-
simply giving up belief: that is, suspending judgment about whether or not anything is knowable.
-
Sextus does allow beliefs, so long as they are not derived by reason, philosophy or speculation; a skeptic may, for example, accept common opinions in the skeptic's society. The important difference between the sceptic and the dogmatist is that the sceptic does not hold his beliefs as a result of rigorous philosophical investigation. In Against the Ethicists, Sextus in fact directly says that "the Skeptic does not conduct his life according to philosophical theory (so far as regards this he is inactive), but as regards the non-philosophical regulation of life he is capable of desiring some things and avoiding others."
-
But he may not believe that such claims are true on the basis of reasons.
-
"dogma" Sextus means "assent to something non-eviden
-
a mental attitude or therapy than a theory. It involves setting things in opposition and owing to the equipollence of the objects and reasons, one suspends judgement. "We oppose either appearances to appearances or objects of thought to objects of thought or alternando
-
-
-
-
"circumstances, conditions or dispositions," t
-
positions, distances, and locations; f
-
all things appear relative, we will suspend judgement about what things exist absolutely and really existent.
[
-
-
-
The New Organon, by Francis Bacon (chapter1) on 2009-11-22
-
-
understand so much and so much only
-
-
instruments and helps that the work is don
-
man can do is to put
together or put asunder natural bodies. The rest is done by nature
working within.
-
xquisite
subtlety and derivations from a few things already known,
-
lready known are due to chance and
experiment rather than to sciences;
-
we neglect to seek for its true helps.
-
logic now in use serves rather to fix and give stability
-
han to help the search after truth
-
syllogism consists of propositions, propositions consist of
words, words are symbols of notions.
-
r only hope therefore lies in a true
induction.
-
ometimes confused
by the flux and alteration of matter
-
necessary that both notions and axioms be derived
from things by a more sure and guarded way,
-
-
-
arrives at the most
general axioms l
-
mind longs to spring up to positions of higher generality, that
it may find rest there, and so after a little while wearies of
experiment
-
understanding left to itself, in a sober, patient, and grave
mind, especially if it be not hindered by received doctrine
-
-
-
is
elicited from facts by a just and methodical process, I call
Interpretation o
-
anticipations are far more
powerful than interpretations,
-
also assert that not much can be known in
nature by the way which is now in use.
-
human understanding is of its own nature prone to suppose
the existence of more order and regularity in the world than it
finds.
-
human understanding when it has once adopted an opinion
(either as being the received opinion or as being agreeable to
itself) draws all things else to support and agree with it.
-
Novum Organum/Preface (Spedding) - Wikisource on 2009-11-22
-
presumption of pronouncing on every thing,
-
despair of comprehending anything; a
-
-
hard thinking and perpetual working and exercise of the mind
-
I open and lay out a new and certain path for the mind to proceed in, starting directly from the simple sensuous perception
-
-
had the effect of fixing errors rather than disclosing truth.
-
e entire work of the understanding be commenced afresh, and the mind itself be from the very outset not left to take its own course, but guided at every step,
-
hand of man it is manifestly impossible, without instruments and machinery, either for the strength of each to be exerted or the strength of all to be united.
-
honour and reverence due to the ancients remains untouched and undiminished;
-
two streams and two dispensations of knowledge;
-
one method for the cultivation, another for the invention, of knowledge.
-
aspires to penetrate further; to overcome, not an adversary in argument, but nature in action; to seek, not pretty and probable conjectures, but certain and demonstrable knowledge
-
Anticipation of the Mind, the other Interpretation of Nature.
-
let him examine the thing thoroughly; let him make some little trial for himself of the way which I describe and lay out; let him familiarise his thoughts with that subtlety of nature to which experience bears witness; let him correct by seasonable patience and due delay the depraved and deep-rooted habits of his mind; and when all this is done and he has begun to be his own master, let him (if he will) use his own judgment.
-
Benedict De Spinoza [Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy] on 2009-11-20
-
The first consists in what he calls infinite and eternal modes. These are pervasive features of the universe,
-
The second consists in what may be called finite and temporal modes, which are simply the
singular things that populate the universe
-
-
t Spinoza ultimately conceives of the relation between infinite and finite modes,
-
: In nature there is nothing contingent, but all things have been determined from the necessity of the divine
nature to exist and produce an effect in a certain way.
-
Spinoza reminds us that God's existence is necessary
-
The knowledge of an effect depends on, and involves, the knowledge of its cause.
-
: The order and connection of ideas is the same as the order and connection of things.
-
t modes
falling under different attributes have no causal interaction but are causally parallel to one another prohibits him
from affirming that mind and body interact
-
the thesis that (1) for each simple
body there exists a simple idea that corresponds to it and from which it is not really distinct and (2) for each
composite body there exists a composite idea that corresponds to it and from which it is not really distinct, composed,
as it were, of ideas corresponding to each of the bodies of which the composite body is composed.
-
The human body, as a highly complex composite of many
simple bodies, is able to act and be acted upon in myriad ways that other bodies cannot. The human mind, as an
expression of that body in the domain of thought, mirrors the body in being a highly complex composite of many simple
ideas and is thus possessed of perceptual capacities exceeding those of other, non-human minds.
-
perceptual ability that is of particular interest to Spinoza is imagination. This he takes to be a general
capacity of representing external bodies as present, whether they are actually present or not. Imagination thus
includes more than the capacity to form those mental constructs that we normally consider to be imaginative. It
includes memory and sense perception as well.
-
, Spinoza consistently opposes imagination to intellect and views it as providing no more than
confused perception.
-
On Spinoza's account, sense perception has its origin in the action of an external body upon one or another of the
sensory organs of one's own body. From this there arises a complex series of changes in what amounts to the body’s
nervous system. As the mind is the idea of the body, it will represent these changes. This, Spinoza contends, is what
constitutes sense perception.
-
e changed state of one's body is a function both of the nature of one’s body and the nature of the external body
that caused that state.
-
y Spinoza judges sense perception to be inadequate. Grounded as it is
in the mind's representation of the state of one’s own body rather than in the direct representation of external bodies,
sense perception is indirect. Since this goes for all imaginative ideas, the problem with them all is the same:
-
Confusion, however, is just one aspect of the inadequacy of imaginative ideas. Such ideas are also mutilated.
-
t it cannot contain ideas of all of the causes of that body.
-
Although imaginative ideas of external bodies are the most important examples of inadequate ideas, they are not
the only examples. Spinoza goes on to show that the mind's ideas of the body, its duration, and its parts are all
inadequate.
-
Spinoza shifts his attention from imaginative ideas of singular things to
intellectual ideas of common things. These common things are things that are either common to all bodies or common to
the human body and certain bodies by which the human body is regularly affected.
-
s result is of utmost importance. Because any idea that follows from an adequate idea is itself adequate, these
ideas, appropriately called common notions, can serve as axioms in a deductive system. When working out this system,
the mind engages in a fundamentally different kind of cognition than when it engages in any of the various forms of
imaginative perception
-
-
f knowledge from random experience
-
-
second kind of knowledge, reason
-
from
an inadequate to an adequate perception of things. This type of knowledge is gained "from the fact that we have common
notions and adequate ideas of the properties of things"
-
a third type, which he regards as superior. He calls this intuitive knowledge
-
understudied areas of Spinoza's thought is his psychology
-
This is the belief in free-will. Spinoza has nothing but
scorn for this belief and treats it as a delusion that arises from the fact that the ideas we have of our actions are
inadequate.
-
-
strives to persevere in being.
-
strives to persevere in its being is nothing but the actual essence of the
thing.
-
. These are the passive affects, or passions. He identifies three as primary - joy, sadness, and desire – and
characterizes all others as involving a combination of one or more of these together with some kind of cognitive state.
Love and hate, for example, are joy and sadness coupled with an awareness of their respective causes. Longing, for
example, is desire coupled with a memory of the desired object and an awareness of its absence. All remaining passions
are characterized in a similar fashion.
-
Although joy, sadness, and desire are primitive, they are each defined in relation to the mind's striving for
perseverance. Joy is that affect by which the mind passes to a greater perfection, understood as an increased power of
striving. Sadness is that affect by which the mind passes to a lesser perfection, understood as a decreased power of
striving. And desire is the striving for perseverance itself insofar as the mind is conscious of it. Because all
passions are derived from these primary affects, the entire passional life of the mind is thus defined in relation to
the striving for perseverance.
-
"The man who is subject to the [passive]
affects," Spinoza writes, "is under the control, not of himself, but of fortune, in whose power he so greatly is that
often, though he sees the better for himself, he is still forced to follow the worse" (IV Preface). Life under the sway
of the passions is a life of bondage.
-
The first is that the mind is a mode of limited power, yet it is inserted into an order of nature
in which there exists an infinite number of modes whose power surpasses its own. To think that the mind can exist
unaffected within this order is to assume, falsely, that it is endowed with infinite power or that nothing in nature
acts upon it. The second, which is a specification of the first, is that an affect is not restrained merely because it
is opposed by reason
-
rather pessimistic diagnosis of the human condition that Spinoza's ethical theory takes off.
-
Spinoza's ethical orientation is much more akin to that of the
ancients than to that of his fellow moderns
-
power of the mind is
defined by knowledge alone, whereas lack of power, or passion, is judged solely by the privation of knowledge, that is,
by that through which ideas are called inadequate" (V
-
e mind is able to form adequate ideas of its affects
-
effect of a thing upon the mind is lessened to the extent that it is understood to be necessary
rather than contingent.
-
e 'free-man' – is one that is lived by the
guidance of reason rather than under the sway of the passions
-
Since reason demands nothing contrary to Nature, it demands that everyone love himself, seek his own
advantage, what is really useful to him, want what will really lead a man to greater perfection, a
-
hat those who live by the guidance of reason will naturally live in harmony with one
another receives some support from his view of the highest good for a human. This is the knowledge of God. Si
-
establish that the knowledge of God is the highest good, Spinoza again appeals to the fact that the mind's
striving is its essence.
-
we strive for from reason is nothing but understanding
-
Knowledge of God is the mind's greatest good: its greatest virtue is to know God.
-
Spinoza's comment that a person who has attained the intellectual love of God "never ceases to be" is perplexing
to say the least
-
The human mind cannot be absolutely destroyed with the body, but something of it remains which is
eternal.
-
Spinoza can
conclude that there is a corresponding distinction with respect to the mind. There is an aspect of the mind that is the
expression of the existence of the body,
-
e acquisition of adequate ideas, especially those by which
we attain knowledge of the third kind, is difficult, and we can never completely escape the influence of the passions.
-
ethica3 on 2009-11-12
-
Our mind is in certain cases active, and in certain cases passive
-
-
-
-
-
mind and body are one and the same thing, c
-
onceived first under the attribute of thought, secondly, under the attribute of extension
-
mind alone can determine whether we speak or are silent, and a variety of similar states which, accordingly, we say depend on the mind's decree.
-
world would be much happier, if men were as fully able to keep silence as they are to speak.
-
ut when we dream that we speak, we
-
mind as that, whereby we keep silence when awake concerning something we know
-
mind two sorts of decisions, one sort illusive, and the other sort free?
-
Nothing can be destroyed, except by a cause external to itself.
-
Everything, in so far as it is in itself,
-
endeavours to persist in its being
-
-
necessarily conscious of itself through the ideas of the modifications of the body, the mind is therefore (
III. vii.) conscious of its own endeavour.
-
generally applied to men, in so far as they are conscious of their appetite, and may accordingly be thus defined: Desire is appetite with consciousness thereo
-
helps or hinders the power of activity in our body,
-
helps or hinders the power of thought in our mind.
-
e mind can undergo many changes,
-
By pleasure therefore in the following propositions I shall signify a passive state wherein the mind passes to a greater perfection. By pain I shall signify a passive state wherein the mind passes to a lesser perfection.
-
Anything can, accidentally, be the cause of pleasure, pain, or desire.
-
object of his love is destroyed
-
-
-
ethica4 on 2009-11-12
-
man is a prey to his emotions, he is not his own master, but lies at the mercy of fortune
-
checking the emotions I name bondage
-
-
-
-
behold something in Nature, which does not wholly conform to the preconceived type which they have formed of the thing
-
men are wont to style natural phenomena perfect or imperfect rather from their own prejudices,
-
Nature does not work with an end in view.
-
he reason or cause why God or Nature exists, and the reason why he acts, are one and the same.
-
Perfection and imperfection, then, are in reality merely modes of thinking, or notions which we form from a comparison a
-
For nothing lies within the scope of a thing's nature, save that which follows from the necessity of the nature of its efficient cause, and whatsoever follows from the necessity of the nature of its efficient cause necessarily comes to pass.
-
-
modes of thinking, or notions which we form from the comparison
-
a means of approaching more nearly to the type of human nature
-
a man passes from a lesser to a greater perfection, or vice versâ, I do not mean that he is changed from one essence or reality to another;
-
-
-
rds, each thing's essence, i
-
more perfect, because it has passed a longer time in existenc
-
-
-
-
-
draw a man in different directions,
-
-
-
-
Groups
Pt chia havn't joined any group yet.
Home
