James Davis's List: Criticisms of technology

A subsequent report pooh-poohed this, so take it with a grain of salt.

researchnews.osu.edu/...facebookusers.htm - Preview

facebook grades critique social_networking on 2009-07-25 and saved by 17 people

What Facebook Users Share: Lower Grades

www.time.com/...0,8599,1891111,00.html - Preview

facebook social_networking on 2009-07-25 and saved by 21 people

There are also links here to many other authors who have been critical of the application of new technologies to education. The site designer also has a blog on technology in education.

www.edtechnot.com/nothealy.html - Preview

psychology child_development educational_technology developmentally_appropriate_teaching child_psychology on 2009-07-25 and saved by 3 people

Something of a follow-up to the Fool's Gold publication, this document more specifically addresses the idea of "technology literacy". It takes a broader view of tech literacy, encouraging the reader to see it as a social thing, not just the ability to use different kinds of software. It contains a good critique of ISTE. Should be mandatory reading for any tech in education program.

www.allianceforchildhood.org/...tech_tonic.pdf - Preview

technology_standards technology_literacy on 2009-07-25 and saved by 6 people

This is a PDF of an important publication challenging the use of technology by young children. It's about eight years old now, but the information in it is more important than ever, as the various standards and pacing guides push technology use down to the lower grades.

drupal6.allianceforchildhood.org/fools_gold - Preview

technology_standards technology_literacy technology_in_education on 2009-07-25 and saved by 6 people

A critical review of the various arguments for using computers in the elementary grades. This is a good summary if you are looking for reasons to oppose aggressive use of technology in lower grades, or want to practice your debating skills to counter the arguments against the arguments etc. The author has written elsewhere about an appropriate tech program (starting at high school).

southerncrossreview.org/...review.html - Preview

computers arguments criticism developmentally-appropriate-technology waldorf on 2009-07-25

An article critical of technology use in K-8 grades. Includes what the authors consider an appropriate technology curriculum, starting in 9th grade. "All technologies are ecological."

www.ime.usp.br/...comp-in-educ.html - Preview

computers alternative curriculum developmentally-appropriate-technology on 2009-07-25

My personal blog on technology and education. The focus continues to shift -- it started out as a communication vehicle for my school community about the tech program at the school; then it shifted to descriptions of my experiences with different technologies; of late I have been focused on developmentally appropriate technology and a sense that we really need to think more critically about what we are doing with technology in schools.

dvorakedtech.blogspot.com - Preview

education educational technology technology on 2009-07-25 and saved by 2 people

Money for technology is flowing at the same time money is being pulled back from traditional programs, leaving some districts with difficult choices. Some of the claims are leaps of fancy from the provided details.

online.wsj.com/...4900904574304140278264598.html - Preview

educational_technology funding on 2009-07-25 and saved by 2 people

A review of Jane Healy's critique of educational technology.

www.gslschool.org/...Failure_to_Connect.pdf - Preview

Jane_Healy failure_to_connect technology_criticism developmentally_appropriate_technology on 2009-07-31