Skip to main content

Diigo Home

The Future of the Internet-And How to Stop It » Chapter 2: Battle of the Netwo... - The Diigo Meta page

yupnet.org/10 - Cached - Annotated View

Group annotations on this page

oD Digest - Future of the Internet Annotation
  • somehow
  • one another.
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-04-30
      But imagine the cost and inconvenience of every appliance having its own network ... so the ability of th enetwork to re-purpose itself is also important to diffusion of technology.
  • connect to it.
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-04-30
      Network architectures and protocols work in an environment in which certain behaviors are assumed ... and new assumptions on behavior lead to new desires for network configuration; trustworthiness is an important such behavioral dimension.
  • networking
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-01
      Regulation, not jsut technology, made it hard to make the telephone network useful for anything apart from telephoning.
  • Hush-A-Phone, which was invented in 1921 as a way to have a conversation without others nearby overhearing it
  • were sold.
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-01
      ATT had control of network adn devices attached to it
  • The court drolly noted, “[AT&T does] not challenge the subscriber’s right to seek privacy. They say only that he should achieve it by cupping his hand between the transmitter and his mouth and speaking in a low voice into this makeshift muffler
  • small ways.
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-01
      Courts forced ATT to accept non-ATT devices on phone system
  • phone network.
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-01
      Court principle in 1940s: "as long as network is not harmed, 3rd parties can hook up to it".
  • The physical layer had become generative, and this generativity meant that additional types of activity in higher layers were made possible.
  • services business
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-01
      The modem on the "open" ATT network was first generative opportunity for hobbyists and businesses
  • THE PROPRIETARY NETWORK MODEL
  • themselves
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-03
      Firt online services were along IBM model but consumer-facing; one company supplied the lot.
  • unchanged
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-03
      In 10 years of business, between 1984 & 2004, Compuserve hardly changed its array of offerings.
  • tinkering
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-03
      Compuserve piggy-backed on ATT network, phy layer generativity, but did ot itself offer 3rd party acces for generativity.
  • Why would the proprietary services not harness the potential generativity of their offerings by making their own servers more open to third-party coding?
  • model prevailed.
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-03
      Information service companies were charging by the minute - so why didn't they want to cultivate 3rd party apps?
  • shopping
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-03
      Probably no one actually saw the commercial potential.
  • free-for-all
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-03
      By early 90s, a small umber of networks offered slightly differentiated, closed, monolithic services.
  • who built them.
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-03
      The answer is probably deep in organisational behavior: mature markets encourage exploitation of niches, not radical exploration of new models.
  • possible.
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-03
      Hobbyist BBS encouraged the opposite incentive of proprietary netowrk: bandwidth limitation meant that users had to be as quick as possible.
  • Jennings’s work
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-03
      FIDOnet - the original p2p file sharing system - got over some of the bandwidth limitations.
  • annoyed person.
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-03
      FIDOnet was a great kludge, but had some real issues - like wrong numbers in the call list ... and irate humans at the end of them.
  • the world
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-03
      FIDOnet problems were exactly the problems that ATT worried about when it wanted to limit 3rd party appliances on the network - who was to blame for quality of service.
  • FIDOnet
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-03
      Internet offered flexibility of FIDOnet with robustness of proprietary network.
  • services
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-04
      PC <--> Internet analogy: Internet connects to proprietary networks and eventually replaces them
  • message
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-04
      From the first, Internet is designed to pass information along diverse computer platforms by defining protocols.
  • points
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-04
      Internet was low level: allow 2 nodes to exchange information ... and that is all; no prejudgement of what people want to do with that information.
  • billion
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-04
      Internet builders were academics who could devote time to the project and yet were doing it for the innate interest; $10m or so spent on Internet between 1969 and 1990 --- great return on investment, from a social point of view.
  • from them.
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-04
      Environment of creation is critical in determining the nature of the system: Internet pioneers were trying to get the most out of existing infrastructure and diverse netwroks; contrast business logic of FedEx network.
  • network work.
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-04
      The motto among Internet pioneers was, “We reject: kings, presidents, and voting. We believe in: rough consensus and running code;” they were building it for themselves, in a sort of Kantian environment of universalisability of the user.
  • controlling it.
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-04
      1991, backbone privatisation context also allowed for decentralisation of network ownership and operation.
  • tryout period
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-04
      Internet -> Windows PC link built by a single academic hobbyist
  • access
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-04
      1991, first opening of Internet to non-research uses; by mid 90s, proprietary networks were branding mainly as ISPs --- generative boom was gathering unbelievable speed.
  • code for it.
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-04
      Internet was built away from commercial logic, no trying to guess what the conusmer wanted; just like the hobbyist PC.
  • harmful code.
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-04
      Basic trade-off: consistency, quality and reliability of service (closed systems) versus breadth of uses, trust of open systems.
  • rust that at least some third-party software writers will write good and useful code, and trust that users of the device will be able to access and sort out the good and useful code from the bad
  • approach
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-04
      Intenret design choices made sense given a sociology, not just an negineering environment.
  • requirements
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-04
      Procrastination principle: 1984 Internet engineer academics formuilate argument that only universally useful features should be built into the network, with other specific work being done at the end-points.
  • Its origins can be found in a 1984 paper by Internet architects David Clark, David Reed, and Jerry Saltzer.
  • The people using this network of networks and configuring its endpoints had to be trusted to be more or less competent and pure enough at heart that they would not intentionally or negligently disrupt the network.
  • persists today.
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-04
      Internet design assumed basic trustworthiness and competence.
  • Yet the assumption that network participants can be trusted, and indeed that they will be participants rather than customers, infuses the Internet’s design at nearly every level.
  • an outsider.
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-04
      Banks are built for robbers, airports for terrorists ... the Internet was built for colleagues.
  • the IDs.
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-04
      AOL/CompServe had identity management built-in: wanted to know who you were for marketing purposes ... good for accountability, too.
  • contents
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-04
      On Internet, identity-management was left to specific service providers or apps to choose.
  • User identification is left to individual Internet users and servers to sort out if they wish to demand credentials of some kind from those with whom they communicate.
  • regulation
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-04
      There's good and bad in internet's anonymity -- can't pursue bad behavers, but can't get the freedom fighters against oppressive governments either -- but an engineering decision has ended up havign huge social impacts.
  • The person at the endpoint must instead rely on falling dominos of trust. The Internet is thus known as a “best efforts” network, sometimes rephrased as “Send it and pray” or “Every packet an adventure.”
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-04
      Internet as "network of networks" loosely cobbled together entails the inability to develop quality of service, or bandwidth agreements, that apply between any 2 points.
  • chapter
    • tonycurzonprice
      Tonycurzonprice on 2008-05-04
      "bit egalitarianism" is assumed in the network, and fixes have been found along the way (eg Akamai & network caching).

    Would you like to comment?

    Join Diigo for a free account, or sign in if you are already a member.