Annals of Medicine: The Cost Conundrum: Reporting & Essays: The New Yorker - The Diigo Meta page

• 18 Nov 09
  

  Hillary Freeman

  Cost Conundrum

• 06 Nov 09
  

  rola hawatmeh
  • failure. At McAllen Heart Hospital, I watched Dyke and a team of six do a
    coronary-artery bypass using technologies that didn’t exist a few years
• 15 Oct 09
  

  Aviva Gabriel

  McAllen TX is one of the most expensive health-care markets in the country. Only Miami-which has much higher labor and living costs-spends more per person on health care. In 2006, Medicare spent fifteen thousand dollars per enrollee here, almost twice the national average. The income per capita is twelve thousand dollars. In other words, Medicare spends three thousand dollars more per person here than the average person earns.

  healthcare costs atul gawande mcallen medicine economics

• 21 Sep 09
  

  Dan Ancona

  econ hcr

• 21 Aug 09
  

  geheimdienst
• 20 Aug 09
  

  Robby Hathaway
  • This last point is vital. Activists and policymakers spend an inordinate amount of time arguing about whether the solution to high medical costs is to have government or private insurance companies write the checks. Here’s how this whole debate goes. Advocates of a public option say government financing would save the most money by having leaner administrative costs and forcing doctors and hospitals to take lower payments than they get from private insurance. Opponents say doctors would skimp, quit, or game the system, and make us wait in line for our care; they maintain that private insurers are better at policing doctors. No, the skeptics say: all insurance companies do is reject applicants who need health care and stall on paying their bills. Then we have the economists who say that the people who should pay the doctors are the ones who use them. Have consumers pay with their own dollars, make sure that they have some “skin in the game,” and then they’ll get the care they deserve. These arguments miss the main issue. When it comes to making care better and cheaper, changing who pays the doctor will make no more difference than changing who pays the electrician. The lesson of the high-quality, low-cost communities is that someone has to be accountable for the totality of care. Otherwise, you get a system that has no brakes. You get McAllen.
• 16 Aug 09
  

  Norman Foo

  health healthcare medicine care cost gawande economics

• 14 Aug 09
  

  David Hughes
• 11 Aug 09
  

  Jim Holincheck

  This is a companion link to the other healthcare link I posted today. There are examples of providing high quality care at lower relative cost. The challenge with healthcare is systemic. The incentives are for doctors to provide more care (more tests, more visits, etc.) not necessarily achieve better outcomes. Until that changes, it does not matter who pays (single payer, private health insurance), we will not have dealt with the root cause of the problem.

• 09 Aug 09
  

  arieswym

  print

• 08 Aug 09
  

  John Riddle

  healthcare Economics care

• 07 Aug 09
  

  dimagg
• 23 Jul 09
  

  Alex Whitlock
• 21 Jul 09
  

  Deborah Batterman
• 29 Jun 09
  

  J Phil Glockner

  health money reference

• 25 Jun 09
  

  Evans Thompson

  ANNALS OF MEDICINE about health-care costs. Writer contrasts the high-cost health-care system in McAllen, Texas, with the lower-cost systems at the Mayo Clinic and in Grand Junction, Colorado. McAllen, Texas is one of the most expensive health-care markets in the country. Only Miami spends more…

  health news

• 22 Jun 09
  

  Erudite

  health healthcare medical money news politics statistics reform Economics medicine costs Texas

  • In 2006, Medicare spent fifteen thousand dollars per enrollee here, almost twice the national average. The income per capita is twelve thousand dollars. In other words, Medicare spends three thousand dollars more per person here than the average person earns.
  • An unhealthy population couldn’t possibly be the reason that McAllen’s health-care costs are so high. (Or the reason that America’s are. We may be more obese than any other industrialized nation, but we have among the lowest rates of smoking and alcoholism, and we are in the middle of the range for cardiovascular disease and diabetes.)
  • 6 more annotations...
  • • The primary cause of McAllen’s extreme costs was, very simply, the across-the-board overuse of medicine.
    • In an odd way, this news is reassuring. Universal coverage won’t be feasible unless we can control costs. Policymakers have worried that doing so would require rationing, which the public would never go along with. So the idea that there’s plenty of fat in the system is proving deeply attractive. “Nearly thirty per cent of Medicare’s costs could be saved without negatively affecting health outcomes if spending in high- and medium-cost areas could be reduced to the level in low-cost areas,” Peter Orszag, the President’s budget director, has stated.
    • differences in decision-making emerged in only some kinds of cases. In situations in which the right thing to do was well established—for example, whether to recommend a mammogram for a fifty-year-old woman (the answer is yes)—physicians in high- and low-cost cities made the same decisions. But, in cases in which the science was unclear, some physicians pursued the maximum possible amount of testing and procedures; some pursued the minimum. And which kind of doctor they were depended on where they came from.

    • Just as an anchor store will define the character of a mall, anchor tenants in biotechnology, whether it’s a company like Genentech, in South San Francisco, or a university like M.I.T., in Cambridge, define the character of an economic community. They set the norms. The anchor tenants that set norms encouraging the free flow of ideas and collaboration, even with competitors, produced enduringly successful communities, while those that mainly sought to dominate did not.

      Powell suspects that anchor tenants play a similarly powerful community role in other areas of economics, too, and health care may be no exception.

    • About fifteen years ago, it seems, something began to change in McAllen. A few leaders of local institutions took profit growth to be a legitimate ethic in the practice of medicine. Not all the doctors accepted this. But they failed to discourage those who did. So here, along the banks of the Rio Grande, in the Square Dance Capital of the World, a medical community came to treat patients the way subprime-mortgage lenders treated home buyers: as profit centers.
    • Instead, McAllen and other cities like it have to be weaned away from their untenably fragmented, quantity-driven systems of health care, step by step. And that will mean rewarding doctors and hospitals if they band together to form Grand Junction-like accountable-care organizations, in which doctors collaborate to increase prevention and the quality of care, while discouraging overtreatment, undertreatment, and sheer profiteering. Under one approach, insurers—whether public or private—would allow clinicians who formed such organizations and met quality goals to keep half the savings they generate. Government could also shift regulatory burdens, and even malpractice liability, from the doctors to the organization. Other, sterner, approaches would penalize those who don’t form these organizations.
• 21 Jun 09
  

  mortsworld .

  Healthcare Atul_Gawande

• 

  anargolwala
• 17 Jun 09
  

  rdbarson

  ANNALS OF MEDICINE about health-care costs. Writer contrasts the high-cost health-care system in McAllen, Texas, with the lower-cost systems at the Mayo Clinic and in Grand Junction, Colorado…

• 16 Jun 09
  

  Karen Tarry
• 

  s. farooq razvi
• 

  lfriedl

  health-insurance medicine

• 15 Jun 09
  

  William Bomash
• 14 Jun 09
  

  Karen Cousins

  Health care

• 13 Jun 09
  

  Jodie Sanders

  by Atul Gawande
  What a Texas town can teach us about health care.

  health money

• 12 Jun 09
  

  tswanick

  economics health care

• 

  Geekgirl 397

  health healthcare medicine Economics cost gawande usa

• 

  Denise Flori

  mcallen tx;healthcare cost; mayo clinic;inefficiencies medicine

• 11 Jun 09
  

  T Cook

  health

• 10 Jun 09
  

  rbosse11
• 

  D D
  • McAllen has another distinction, too: it is one of the most expensive health-care markets in the country. Only Miami—which has much higher labor and living costs—spends more per person on health care. In 2006, Medicare spent fifteen thousand dollars per enrollee here, almost twice the national average. The income per capita is twelve thousand dollars. In other words, Medicare spends three thousand dollars more per person here than the average person earns.
  • Our country’s health care is by far the most expensive in the world. In Washington, the aim of health-care reform is not just to extend medical coverage to everybody but also to bring costs under control. Spending on doctors, hospitals, drugs, and the like now consumes more than one of every six dollars we earn.
  • 85 more annotations...
  • • The financial burden has damaged the global competitiveness of American businesses and bankrupted millions of families, even those with insurance.
    • El Paso County, eight hundred miles up the border, has essentially the same demographics.
    • et in 2006 Medicare expenditures (our best approximation of over-all spending patterns) in El Paso were $7,504 per enrollee—half as much as in McAllen.
    • n unhealthy population couldn’t possibly be the reason that McAllen’s health-care costs are so high.

    • we have among the lowest rates of smoking and alcoholism, and we are in the middle of the range for cardiovascular disease and diabetes.)

    • providing unusually good health care?

    • And yet there’s no evidence that the treatments and technologies available at McAllen are better than those found elsewhere in the country.

    • Nor does the care given in McAllen stand out for its quality.

    • On all but two of these, McAllen’s five largest hospitals performed worse, on average, than El Paso’s.
    • McAllen costs Medicare seven thousand dollars more per person each year than does the average city in America.

    • . Several years ago, Texas passed a tough malpractice law that capped pain-and-suffering awards at two hundred and fifty thousand dollars. Didn’t lawsuits go down?

      “Practically to zero,” the cardiologist admitted.

    • There is overutilization here, pure and simple.” Doctors, he said, were racking up charges with extra tests, services, and procedures.
    • Everyone agreed that something fundamental had changed since the days when health-care costs in McAllen were the same as those in El Paso and elsewhere.
    • McAllen surgeons simply operate
    • And by operating they happen to make an extra seven hundred dollars.
    • To determine whether overuse of medical care was really the problem in McAllen
    • The answer was yes. Compared with patients in El Paso and nationwide, patients in McAllen got more of pretty much everything—more diagnostic testing, more hospital treatment, more surgery, more home care.
    • overuse of medicine.
    • For example, Rochester, Minnesota, where the Mayo Clinic dominates the scene, has fantastically high levels of technological capability and quality, but its Medicare spending is in the lowest fifteen per cent of the country
    • per enrollee
    • In fact, the four states with the highest levels of spending—Louisiana, Texas, California, and Florida—were near the bottom of the national rankings on the quality of patient care.
    • some hundred thousand people die each year from complications of surgery—far more than die in car crashes.
    • To make matters worse, Fisher found that patients in high-cost areas were actually less likely to receive low-cost preventive services, such as flu and pneumonia vaccines, faced longer waits at doctor and emergency-room visits, and were less likely to have a primary-care physician. They got more of the stuff that cost more, but not more of what they needed.
    • If we brought the cost curve in the expensive places down to their level, Medicare’s problems (indeed, almost all the federal government’s budget problems for the next fifty years) would be solved
    • revenues of five billion dollars last year
    • It is physician-owned. And it has a reputation (which it disclaims) for aggressively recruiting high-volume physicians to become investors and send patients there.
    • also a percentage of the hospital’s profits from the tests, surgery, or other care patients are given.
    • Romero and others argued that this gives physicians an unholy temptation to overorder.
    • What he gave me was a disquisition on the theory and history of American health-care financing going back to Lyndon Johnson and the creation of Medicare, the upshot of which was: (1) Government is the problem in health care. “The people in charge of the purse strings don’t know what they’re doing.” (2) If anything, government insurance programs like Medicare don’t pay enough. “I, as an anesthesiologist, know that they pay me ten per cent of what a private insurer pays.” (3) Government programs are full of waste. “Every person in this room could easily go through the expenditures of Medicare and Medicaid and see all kinds of waste.” (4) But not in McAllen.
    • In the end, the only explanation he and his colleagues could offer was this: The other doctors and hospitals in McAllen may be overspending, but, to the extent that his hospital provides costlier treatment than other places in the country, it is making people better in ways that data on quality and outcomes do not measure.
    • Local executives for hospitals
    • know that if their doctors bring in enough business—surgery, imaging, home-nursing referrals—they make money; and if they get the doctors to bring in more, they make more.
    • Health-care costs ultimately arise from the accumulation of individual decisions doctors make
    • The most expensive piece of medical equipment, as the saying goes, is a doctor’s pen.
    • he and her team surveyed some eight hundred primary-care physicians from high-cost cities (such as Las Vegas and New York), low-cost cities (such as Sacramento and Boise), and others in between. The researchers asked the physicians specifically how they would handle a variety of patient cases.
    • But, in cases in which the science was unclear, some physicians pursued the maximum possible amount of testing and procedures; some pursued the minimum. And which kind of doctor they were depended on where they came from.

    • But physicians from the most expensive cities did the most expensive things.

    • One morning, I met with a hospital administrator who had extensive experience managing for-profit hospitals along the border. He offered a different possible explanation: the culture of money.
    • “In El Paso, if you took a random doctor and looked at his tax returns eighty-five per cent of his income would come from the usual practice of medicine,” he said. But in McAllen, the administrator thought, that percentage would be a lot less.
    • But he had often seen financial considerations drive the decisions doctors made for patients
    • No one teaches you how to think about money in medical school or residency. Yet, from the moment you start practicing, you must think about it.
    • many physicians are remarkably oblivious to the financial implications of their decisions.
    • Others think of the money as a means of improving what they do.
    • Then there are the physicians who see their practice primarily as a revenue stream
    • so that the insurance payments go to them rather than to the hospital. They figure out ways to increase their high-margin work and decrease their low-margin work.
    • he’d seen the behavior cross over into what seemed like outright fraud. “I’ve had doctors here come up to me and say, ‘You want me to admit patients to your hospital, you’re going to have to pay me.’ ”
    • he had never been asked for a kickback before coming to McAllen.
    • The answer they found was what Powell describes as the anchor-tenant theory of economic development. Just as an anchor store will define the character of a mall, anchor tenants in biotechnology, whether it’s a company like Genentech, in South San Francisco, or a university like M.I.T., in Cambridge, define the character of an economic community. They set the norms. The anchor tenants that set norms encouraging the free flow of ideas and collaboration, even with competitors, produced enduringly successful communities, while those that mainly sought to dominate did not.
    • Powell suspects that anchor tenants play a similarly powerful community role in other areas of economics, too
    • She described how, a decade or so ago, a few early agencies began rewarding doctors who ordered home visits with more than trinkets: they provided tickets to professional sporting events, jewelry, and other gifts. That set the tone.
    • About fifteen years ago, it seems, something began to change in McAllen. A few leaders of local institutions took profit growth to be a legitimate ethic in the practice of medicine.
    • Every incentive in the system is an invitation to go the way McAllen has gone. Yet, across the country, large numbers of communities have managed to control their health costs rather than ratchet them up.
    • Mayo Clinic, which is among the highest-quality, lowest-cost health-care systems in the country
    • The whole interaction was astonishing to me. Just having the cardiologist pop down to see the patient with the surgeon would be unimaginable at my hospital. The time required wouldn’t pay. The time required just to organize the system wouldn’t pay.
    • The core tenet of the Mayo Clinic is “The needs of the patient come first”—not the convenience of the doctors, not their revenues. The doctors and nurses, and even the janitors, sat in meetings almost weekly, working on ideas to make the service and the care better, not to get more money out of patients. I
    • liminate the financial barriers. It pooled all the money the doctors and the hospital system received and began paying everyone a salary, so that the doctors’ goal in patient care couldn’t be increasing their income
    • almost by happenstance, the result has been lower costs.
    • It was difficult to recruit staff members who would accept a salary and the Mayo’s collaborative way of practicing.
    • eventually they achieved the same high-quality, low-cost results
    • One of the lowest-cost markets in the country is Grand Junction, Colorado, a community of a hundred and twenty thousand that nonetheless has achieved some of Medicare’s highest quality-of-care scores.
    • years ago the doctors agreed among themselves to a system that paid them a similar fee whether they saw Medicare, Medicaid, or private-insurance patients, so that there would be little incentive to cherry-pick patients. They also agreed, at the behest of the main health plan in town, an H.M.O., to meet regularly on small peer-review committees to go over their patient charts together.
    • in 2004, the doctors’ group and the local H.M.O. jointly created a regional information network
    • problems went down. Quality went up. And costs ended up lower
    • than just about anywhere else in the United States.
    • an accountable-care organization.
    • adopted in other places, too
    • we are witnessing a battle for the soul of American medicine
    • the damning question we have to ask is whether the doctor is set up to meet the needs of the patient, first and foremost, or to maximize revenue.
    • having a system that does so much to misalign them has proved disastrous.
    • we pay doctors for quantity, not quality.
    • health care is like building a house.
    • Would you be surprised if you got a house with a thousand outlets, faucets, and cabinets, at three times the cost you expected, and the whole thing fell apart a couple of years later?
    • Here’s how this whole debate goes.
    • These arguments miss the main issue. When it comes to making care better and cheaper, changing who pays the doctor will make no more difference than changing who pays the electrician. The lesson of the high-quality, low-cost communities is that someone has to be accountable for the totality of care.
    • “We took a wrong turn when doctors stopped being doctors and became businessmen,” he said.
    • “Any plan that relies on the sheep to negotiate with the wolves is doomed to failure.”
    • cities like it have to be weaned away from their untenably fragmented, quantity-driven systems of health care, step by step. And that will mean rewarding doctors and hospitals if they band together to form Grand Junction-like accountable-care organizations, in which doctors collaborate to increase prevention and the quality of care, while discouraging overtreatment, undertreatment, and sheer profiteering
    • We will need to do in-depth research on what makes the best systems successfu
    • we also need to fund research that compares the effectiveness of different systems of care
    • we would do well to form a national institute for health-care delivery
    • savings will take at least a decade.
    • But a choice must be made. Whom do we want in charge of managing the full complexity of medical care?
    • the war over whether our country’s anchor model will be Mayo or McAllen—the Mayo model is losing.
    • many people in medicine don’t see why they should do the hard work of organizing themselves in ways that reduce waste and improve quality if it means sacrificing revenue.
    • “some of the doctors are beginning to complain about ‘leaving money on the table.’ ”
• 09 Jun 09
  

  Frank Sanders

  healthcare politics cost economics

• 08 Jun 09
  

  chellery stick

  medicine health economics

• 

  Lisa Spiro

  collaboration

• 03 Jun 09
  

  vikram singh

  healthcare Cost gawande

• 02 Jun 09
  

  Takuya Homma
• 01 Jun 09
  

  Scott Winship

  This is deservedly drawing wide praise for explaining why health care costs are too high.

  healthcare health new yorker gawande

• 

  [MUST read]
  When you look across the spectrum from Grand Junction to McAllen—and the almost threefold difference in the costs of care—you come to realize that we are witnessing a battle for the soul of American medicine...When it comes to making care bett

  healthcare reform texas entrepreneur corruption

  • nothing in medicine is without risks. Complications can arise from hospital stays, medications, procedures, and tests, and when these things are of marginal value the harm can be greater than the benefits.
  • Most Americans would be delighted to have the quality of care found in places like Rochester, Minnesota, or Seattle, Washington, or Durham, North Carolina—all of which have world-class hospitals and costs that fall below the national average. If we brought the cost curve in the expensive places down to their level, Medicare’s problems (indeed, almost all the federal government’s budget problems for the next fifty years) would be solved. The difficulty is how to go about it. Physicians in places like McAllen behave differently from others. The $2.4-trillion question is why. Unless we figure it out, health reform will fail.
  • 4 more annotations...
  • • Renaissance. It is the newest hospital in the area. It is physician-owned. And it has a reputation (which it disclaims) for aggressively recruiting high-volume physicians to become investors and send patients there. Physicians who do so receive not only their fee for whatever service they provide but also a percentage of the hospital’s profits from the tests, surgery, or other care patients are given. (In 2007, its profits totalled thirty-four million dollars.) Romero and others argued that this gives physicians an unholy temptation to overorder.

    • “In El Paso, if you took a random doctor and looked at his tax returns eighty-five per cent of his income would come from the usual practice of medicine,” he said. But in McAllen, the administrator thought, that percentage would be a lot less.

      He knew of doctors who owned strip malls, orange groves, apartment complexes—or imaging centers, surgery centers, or another part of the hospital they directed patients to. They had “entrepreneurial spirit,” he said. They were innovative and aggressive in finding ways to increase revenues from patient care. “There’s no lack of work ethic,” he said. But he had often seen financial considerations drive the decisions doctors made for patients—the tests they ordered, the doctors and hospitals they recommended—and it bothered him. Several doctors who were unhappy about the direction medicine had taken in McAllen told me the same thing. “It’s a machine, my friend,” one surgeon explained.

    • Woody Powell is a Stanford sociologist who studies the economic culture of cities. Recently, he and his research team studied why certain regions—Boston, San Francisco, San Diego—became leaders in biotechnology while others with a similar concentration of scientific and corporate talent—Los Angeles, Philadelphia, New York—did not. The answer they found was what Powell describes as the anchor-tenant theory of economic development. Just as an anchor store will define the character of a mall, anchor tenants in biotechnology, whether it’s a company like Genentech, in South San Francisco, or a university like M.I.T., in Cambridge, define the character of an economic community. They set the norms. The anchor tenants that set norms encouraging the free flow of ideas and collaboration, even with competitors, produced enduringly successful communities, while those that mainly sought to dominate did not.
    • This approach has been adopted in other places, too: the Geisinger Health System, in Danville, Pennsylvania; the Marshfield Clinic, in Marshfield, Wisconsin; Intermountain Healthcare, in Salt Lake City; Kaiser Permanente, in Northern California. All of them function on similar principles. All are not-for-profit institutions. And all have produced enviably higher quality and lower costs than the average American town enjoys.
• 31 May 09
  

  stubeth2
• 

  Jos Aarts

  Health care costs Texas

• 

  zanefaulkner
• 30 May 09
  

  charlesijones

  McAllen calls itself the Square Dance Capital of the World. “Lonesome Dove” was set around here. McAllen has another distinction, too: it is one of the most expensive health-care markets in the country. Only Miami—which has much higher labor and living costs—spends more per person on health care. In 2006, Medicare spent fifteen thousand dollars per enrollee here, almost twice the national average. The income per capita is twelve thousand dollars. In other words, Medicare spends three thousand dollars more per person here than the average person earns. The explosive trend in American medical costs seems to have occurred here in an especially intense form. ... The question we’re now frantically grappling with is how this came to be, and what can be done about it. McAllen, Texas, the most expensive town in the most expensive country for health care in the world, seemed a good place to look for some answers.

• 

  Todd Suomela

  medicine health cost economics

• 29 May 09
  

  Robert D Fraser
• 

  vineet01
• 28 May 09
  

  Eldritch Crank

  The leading doctors and the hospital system adopted measures to blunt harmful financial incentives, and they took collective responsibility for improving the sum total of patient care.

  medicine health health care

• 

  jgar535

  vanity fair article comparing mcallen, tx vs el paso, tx cost differentials

  health care

• 

  T. Rex Bean

  gawande newyorker healthcare

• 27 May 09
  

  lewell gunter
• 

  finnegas

  The core tenet of the Mayo Clinic is “The needs of the patient come first”—not the convenience of the doctors, not their revenues. The doctors and nurses, and even the janitors, sat in meetings almost weekly, working on ideas to make the service and the care better, not to get more money out of patients. I asked Cortese how the Mayo Clinic made this possible.
  
  “It’s not easy,” he said. But decades ago Mayo recognized that the first thing it needed to do was eliminate the financial barriers. It pooled all the money the doctors and the hospital system received and began paying everyone a salary, so that the doctors’ goal in patient care couldn’t be increasing their income. Mayo promoted leaders who focussed first on what was best for patients, and then on how to make this financially possible.

  Communiity development user orientated

  • became leaders in biotechnology while others with a similar concentration of scientific and corporate talent—Los Angeles, Philadelphia, New York—did not. The answer they found was what Powell describes as the anchor-tenant theory of economic development. Just as an anchor store will define the character of a mall, anchor tenants in biotechnology, whether it’s a company like Genentech, in South San Francisco, or a university like M.I.T., in Cambridge, define the character of an economic community. They set the norms. The anchor tenants that set norms encouraging the free flow of ideas and collaboration, even with competitors, produced enduringly successful communities, while those that mainly sought to dominate did not.
  • Grand Junction’s medical community was not following anyone else’s recipe. But, like Mayo, it created what Elliott Fisher, of Dartmouth, calls an accountable-care organization. The leading doctors and the hospital system adopted measures to blunt harmful financial incentives, and they took collective responsibility for improving the sum total of patient care.
  • 3 more annotations...
  • • As they point out less often, we also pay them as individuals, rather than as members of a team working together for their patients. Both practices have made for serious problems.

    • Nor will changing the person who writes him the check.

      This last point is vital. Activists and policymakers spend an inordinate amount of time arguing about whether the solution to high medical costs is to have government or private insurance companies write the checks.

    • And that will mean rewarding doctors and hospitals if they band together to form Grand Junction-like accountable-care organizations, in which doctors collaborate to increase prevention and the quality of care, while discouraging overtreatment, undertreatment, and sheer profiteering.

Would you like to comment?

Join Diigo for a free account, or sign in if you are already a member.