Skip to main content

Diigo Home

Eurozine - Blogging, the nihilist impulse - Geert Lovink - The Diigo Meta page

www.eurozine.com/...2007-01-02-lovink-en.html - Cached - Annotated View

tony curzon price's personal annotations on this page

tonycurzonprice
Tonycurzonprice bookmarked on 2008-02-26 blogging lovink macarthur culture nihilism web2.0


There is a quest for truth in blogging. But it is a truth with a question mark. Truth has become an amateur project, not an absolute value, sanctioned by higher authorities. I

  • Can we talk of a "fear of media freedom"? It is too easy to say that there is freedom of speech and that blogs materialize this right. The aim of radical freedom, one could argue, is to create autonomy and overcome the dominance of media corporations and state control and to no longer be bothered by "their" channels. Most blogs show an opposite tendency. The obsession with news factoids borders to the extreme. Instead of selective appropriation, there is over-identification and straight out addiction, in particular to the speed of real-time reporting. Like Erich Fromm (author of Fear of Freedom), we could read this as "a psychological problem" because existing information is simply reproduced and in a public act of internalization. Lists of books that still have to be read, a common feature on blogs, lead in the same direction. According to Fromm, freedom has put us in an unbearable isolation. We thus feel anxious and powerless. Either we escape into new dependencies or realize a positive freedom that is based upon "the uniqueness and individuality of man".[49] "The right to express our thoughts means something only if we are able to have thoughts of our own."[50] The freedom from traditional media monopolies leads to new bondages, in this case to the blog paradigm, where there is little emphasis on positive freedom, on what to with the overwhelming functionality and the void of the empty, white entry window. We do not hear enough about the tension between the individual self and the "community", "swarms", and "mobs" that are supposed to be part of the online environment. What we instead see happening on the software side are daily improvements of ever more sophisticated (quantitive) measuring and manipulation tools (in terms of inbound linking, traffic, climbing higher on the Google ladder, etc.). Isn't the document that stands out the one that is not embedded in existing contexts? Doesn't the truthness lie in the unlinkable?

This link has been bookmarked by 25 people . It was first bookmarked on 03 Jan 2007, by Peter Giger.

  • 19 Dec 09
    • It is of strategic importance to develop critical categories of a theory of blogging that takes the specific mixture of technology, interface design, software architecture, and social networking into account.
    • Blogging did not emerge out of a movement or an event. If anything, it is a special effect of software, constituted especially by the automation of links, a not-overly-complex technical interface design issue.
  • 20 Sep 08
    katepe
    katarina peovic

    I see blogs as part of an unfolding process of "massification" of this still new medium. What the Internet lost after 2000 was the "illusion of change".

    blogtheory newmediastudies cybertheory lovink

  • 20 Jun 08
    ognjen
    Ognjen Strpić

    Can we talk of a "fear of media freedom"? freedom has put us in an unbearable isolation. We thus feel anxious and powerless. "The right to express our thoughts means something only if we are able to have thoughts of our own

    web writing philosophy technology publishing

  • 26 Feb 08
    tonycurzonprice
    tony curzon price


    There is a quest for truth in blogging. But it is a truth with a question mark. Truth has become an amateur project, not an absolute value, sanctioned by higher authorities. I

    blogging lovink macarthur culture nihilism web2.0

    • Can we talk of a "fear of media freedom"? It is too easy to say that there is freedom of speech and that blogs materialize this right. The aim of radical freedom, one could argue, is to create autonomy and overcome the dominance of media corporations and state control and to no longer be bothered by "their" channels. Most blogs show an opposite tendency. The obsession with news factoids borders to the extreme. Instead of selective appropriation, there is over-identification and straight out addiction, in particular to the speed of real-time reporting. Like Erich Fromm (author of Fear of Freedom), we could read this as "a psychological problem" because existing information is simply reproduced and in a public act of internalization. Lists of books that still have to be read, a common feature on blogs, lead in the same direction. According to Fromm, freedom has put us in an unbearable isolation. We thus feel anxious and powerless. Either we escape into new dependencies or realize a positive freedom that is based upon "the uniqueness and individuality of man".[49] "The right to express our thoughts means something only if we are able to have thoughts of our own."[50] The freedom from traditional media monopolies leads to new bondages, in this case to the blog paradigm, where there is little emphasis on positive freedom, on what to with the overwhelming functionality and the void of the empty, white entry window. We do not hear enough about the tension between the individual self and the "community", "swarms", and "mobs" that are supposed to be part of the online environment. What we instead see happening on the software side are daily improvements of ever more sophisticated (quantitive) measuring and manipulation tools (in terms of inbound linking, traffic, climbing higher on the Google ladder, etc.). Isn't the document that stands out the one that is not embedded in existing contexts? Doesn't the truthness lie in the unlinkable?
  • 16 Jan 08
  • 24 Oct 07
  • 11 Jul 07
    • As much as "democratization" means "engaged citizens", it also implies normalization (as in setting of norms) and banalization. We can't separate these elements and only enjoy the interesting bits.
    • Despite countless attempts to feature blogs as alternatives to mainstream media, they are often, more precisely described as "feedback channels".
    • 3 more annotations...
  • 26 Jun 07
  • 04 May 07
  • 30 Mar 07
  • 08 Mar 07
  • 09 Jan 07
    mbauwens
    Michel Bauwens

    I think the cynicism is more on the part of the author <g>

    Blogosphere P2P

  • 06 Jan 07
  • 05 Jan 07
  • 04 Jan 07
  • 03 Jan 07
    • Commonly associated with the pessimistic belief that all of existence is meaningless, nihilism would be an ethical doctrine that there are no moral absolutes or infallible natural laws and that "truth" is inescapably subjective.
    • Nihilism is no longer a danger or problem, but the default postmodern condition.
    • 19 more annotations...