This link has been bookmarked by 1 people . It was first bookmarked on 05 Dec 2007, by Wisely.
-
05 Dec 07
-
Reply by Harold Jarche Oct 13
My attention is spread between my blog, comments, other's blogs, Facebook, Ning, social bookmarks and a few other social spaces. My best (?) thoughts usually go on my blog. If you added up all of the aggregate conversations of these 165 members there is probably much more depth than we see here. Perhaps we just have too many online options today. -
Permalink Reply by Andy Jones Oct 15
Finally someone has said it. I'm surprised (and pleased) it's you. You're right - this is a bit, erm, treacle like. I'm a full throttle, get involved, interact, shout, rant, think type of person (in case you hadn't guessed).
Internet time is where I put my ideas to the test of the community.
Because, as you said, there are some really good minds here (so what are YOU doing here I hear you ask) then I get some really good insite, ideas etc. If it wasn't there, I'd be going it alone.
We could become a stellar "think tank". STELLAR. With the knowledge, experience and wisdom sloshing around here then all everyone needs to do is contribute once every 40 days and we'd still get 4 new posts a day. Simple that way right. Imagine being able to ask the help of 167 other people from all over the world who are willing to help?
For those of you reading this thinking "but Andy, I can't write sparkling and witty prose like you". Spit it out and we'll work it out! Jay's made it clear that the rules are to play nice - so you're not going to get attacked or ridiculed (because if you did I'd be gone long ago - I once suggested that Lobster was a realistic currency - no seriously!).
Anyway - enough of the rambling. Jay - we're going to need to do some kicking but I think we're going to get somewhere. -
Permalink Reply by Bill Bruck Oct 15
-
Permalink Reply by Bill Bruck Oct 15
-
I'd like to suggest three points for your/our consideration: technology, you, and us.
Technology
Ning is a nice platform. But I see it as more of a social networking platform (designed for weak ties and occasional interactions among larger numbers of people) rather than an online community platform (designed for stronger ties and regular interactions among a smaller group of people). -
The affordances for the two types of platforms differ in subtle but socially important ways. Things like the ability to quickly and easily read all new posts, to participate by email (I was told that's so Web 1.0, but it's important to me at any rate, and would up particiption 100% to see and reply to things from my Outlook inbox); etc.
-
You
I've become convinced - and you've heard me say so in my talks - that self-organizing start-up communities just don't work very often. They need a strange attractor to get things going and build the momentum to where they have a change of being self organizing. They need a wedding planner - someone to take stewardship for creating a coffee shop and seeding it with some great discussion items. They need an event planner - someone to ask the equivalent of the leaning circuits "big question" of the month. They need a facilitator to ensure that every post is responded to - and not simply by the facilitator - so much facilitation is back channel, bringing in "ringers," etc.
Bottom line - I hate to be blunt about this - but this is your community. It's your social capital that has me taking half an hour of my time posting here, and coming back from time to time to see what's happening - but now less and less, and there's not much going on. -
Us
That having been said, it's not enough to have a robust platform and charismatic strange attractor(s). The soil has to be fertile and the time right to plant the seeds. That soil is us, and I'm not sure how fertile a field we are. Harold said it already - he spends his time planting seeds in his own field. -
I would suggest that a lot of it, in our field, is driven by the desire for personal branding. Folks want to make a name for themselves. In fact, for many, online personal branding is a (the?) cornerstone of building their own reputation in the field, and even generating visibility and buzz that will lead to consulting and other contracts.
I believe blogs are much better than participating in someone else's community for this. -
So, I guess another question to ask or factor to consider is this: Of the 165 folks who include some of the best minds in learning - how much appetite is there actually to simply be an indian and not a chief? To be part of a community and not the start of our own one-person play?
How much to we want to sing together in a chorus (or have hilarious disagreements in the local pub) v. stand on our own soapbox in Hyde Park to proclaim our view of the world to passers-by? -
I WAS, in fact, suggesting as a possibility that many of us "learning professionals" may, in fact, put our online posting energies into building our brand and marketing, and have very little left for participation in online communities that will offer less in this regard.
In know it's a rather bold statement, and in fact, may be offensive to some, for which I apologize in advance. But as I compare the sharing I experience in other online venues with what I observe in the learning community, it seems like folks have much more energy for posting where it will build their brand. I actually don't have a lot of judgment about this, but I do suspect it may be true. -
active stewardship needs to take place in order to maximize the possbility that the community will grow.
-
This space is not a community. It's a community center - the online "building" in which a community can meet.
You probably have a commuity center near your house. But there's no one in it now, because there's no basketball game going on. Community centers - be they online or bricks and morter - need to have basketball games and other activities in order to attract people. And we're all busy folks. We need sometone to organize and structure these activities to build a vibrant community. -
Reply by Jay Cross Oct 15
-
I particularly like Bill's suggestion that we fill the event planner role.
-
I'm surprised by this talk about each of us gardening our own plots. Indeed, blogs are a wonderful tool for self-promotion. But that's not what you come here for. This is not a blog; it's a place
-
To play on another of Bill's analogies, the basketball game is here. Be here now. You can sit in the stands or join the action on the court. I take part to improve my game.
-
I like the idea of an active stewardship to boost the allround activity in the community.
-
Would you like to comment?
Join Diigo for a free account, or sign in if you are already a member.