Skip to main content

Diigo Home

Yes I Can - Stanley Fish Blog - NYTimes.com - The Diigo Meta page

fish.blogs.nytimes.com/...yes-i-can - Cached - Annotated View

Levy Rivers's personal annotations on this page

oldude59
Oldude59 bookmarked on 2009-06-08 obama Fish
  • No doubt this pattern of pronouns reflects a reality. By all the evidence we have, the guy’s completely in charge, making decisions, giving instructions, deploying resources, assigning tasks — a combination point guard, quarterback and clean-up hitter. And if he gets results, as he seems to be doing, that’s O.K.


    But it may not be O.K., as a matter of rhetoric and politics, to advertise it. An occasional passive construction to soften the claim of agency would be a good idea (even though the grammar books warn against it). It’s one thing to be calling the tune; it’s another to proclaim it in every sentence. Someone is going to say, “Am I the only one who thinks that Obama likes the sound of his own voice?” (Sea Urchin, here).

This link has been bookmarked by 9 people . It was first bookmarked on 08 Jun 2009, by Mauro Calcagno.

  • 14 Jul 09
  • 09 Jun 09
  • 08 Jun 09
    armaalma
    armando almeida

    Os pronomes pessoais

    OBAMA

    • No doubt this pattern of pronouns reflects a reality. By all the evidence we have, the guy’s completely in charge, making decisions, giving instructions, deploying resources, assigning tasks — a combination point guard, quarterback and clean-up hitter. And if he gets results, as he seems to be doing, that’s O.K.


      But it may not be O.K., as a matter of rhetoric and politics, to advertise it. An occasional passive construction to soften the claim of agency would be a good idea (even though the grammar books warn against it). It’s one thing to be calling the tune; it’s another to proclaim it in every sentence. Someone is going to say, “Am I the only one who thinks that Obama likes the sound of his own voice?” (Sea Urchin, here).