Skip to main content

Diigo Home

Military brass joins wired troops | csmonitor.com - The Diigo Meta page

features.csmonitor.com/...itary-brass-joins-wired-troops - Cached - Annotated View

Public Stiky Notes

  • TransTracker
    TransTracker on 2009-02-02
    Allen...as in, Adm. Thad Allen, Commandant of the Coast Guard. This is interesting, because the value of blogging in this case is framed in terms of commander's intent and the promotion of initiative at lower levels. Commander's intent and initiative are not new concepts. Rather, they have been key ideas in 20th century military thought, especially among WWII-era German military thinkers and American advocates of maneuver warfare and AirLand Battle during the 1980s. These ideas continue to be widely accepted within U.S. military discourse.
  • TransTracker
    TransTracker on 2009-02-02
    There seems to be an issue developing over the internal versus external value of blogs and other social media. In the case of Adm. Allen, the main identified value is mainly internal--i.e. internal to the military organization itself. In this case, public affairs in more external. However, because social media takes place publicly--i.e. even a commander blog meant for internal consumption would be publicly available--then the internal/external boundary blurs to a significant degree. But it's that blurring that helps to add legitimacy and to spark interest among potential readers. Where the military is concerned, readers will be more interested if they think they are getting an "inside scoop" not previously available to them. Those blogs that have more of a personal, insider kind of feel will likely be more successful than those blogs that really just use a new delivery mechanism to deliver the same old press releases, etc.
  • TransTracker
    TransTracker on 2009-02-02
    "Wiki security"....that's a new term for me! Interesting idea. Not entirely well thought-out yet, but interesting nonetheless and not entirely without promise.

    The other interesting thing here, however, is the conflation of blogging and Facebook. That seems to happen repeatedly in this article. Is that a result of the reporter conflating the two, or him reflecting his military subjects conflating the two?
  • TransTracker
    TransTracker on 2009-02-02
    John Nagl is refering here to the Small Wars Journal. I don't think he's entirely correct, however. Though SMJ has created more and faster discourse, it is not entirely accurate to imply that discourse was discouraged before. One thing that I found in my disssertation research is that "the military" is a much more open place than most would assume. There is a lot of debate, idea generation, etc. that happens both "inside" and "outside" the military, which ultimately impacts doctrine and strategy. This was especially the case during the debates over maneuver warfare and AirLand Battle during the 1980s. Though there have been setbacks along the way, in general, the military has become progressively both more open to "outsiders," as well as more an intellectual, debate-prone arena between 1945 and the present.

    Would you like to comment?

    Join Diigo for a free account, or sign in if you are already a member.